## Results of catalyst tests

For discussion of specific patterns or specific families of patterns, both newly-discovered and well-known.
Scorbie
Posts: 1443
Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am

### Results of catalyst tests

I wrote:I personally think it would be thankful if you write a post on an existing topic instead of opening a new topic, but I'm not sure if others would agree with that.
I feel a little guilty for acting against my own words... But I thought this was something worth sharing. Well I'm planning to post results from another tl;dr utility I posted. Hopefully the results would be more interesting than the explanation.

So exactly what did I do?
1) I generated random soups.
2) I counted the number of unique perturbations.

EDIT: The word "unique" is kinda ambiguous now. I first filtered out reactions that are really trivial, like these:

Code: Select all

x = 33, y = 29, rule = B3/S23
16bo$15bo$15bo$15bo$16bobo$12bo4bo$8b2obobo$6bo2bob2o$6b2o2bo$11bobo$
12b2o4$3bo25bo$2bo27bo2$bo23bo5bo$24bo$24bo$o8b5o10bo7bo$25bobo$o8b5o
7bo4bo5bo$20bobo$20b2o$bo29bo2$2bo27bo$3bo25bo! But now changed the source code to filter non-obvious duplicates like these, too: Code: Select all x = 19, y = 11, rule = B3/S23 2bo12bo$3b3o10b3o$3bo12bo2$b2obo2bo7b2o$2bob4o7b2o$obo$2o2b2o$5bo$4bo$
4b2o!
EDIT: Here's the results of the latest search as of Nov 29, 2015, with catalysts with a frequency > 0.1 in the preceding search.
The search was conducted in Nov 21st, I think.
I accidentally made a mistake on the spartan catalysts, and the transparent loaf contains noise of the "rock-tub" catalyses. Without it, the frequency should be around 0.1 (result from the preceding search.)

Code: Select all

x = 466, y = 192, rule = LifeHistory
422.2C5.2C$19.D5.D10.3D3.3D3.3D24.2C11.3D11.D5.D3.3D32.A10.3D9.3D4.D 4.3D43.3D10.D6.D5.D29.2A3.C8.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D31.2A10.3D9.3D5.D3.3D27.A. A3.A.A7.3D9.3D3.3D2.5D$18.2D4.2D9.D3.D.D5.D3.D23.A.A9.D3.D9.2D4.2D2.D
3.D28.A.A.A8.D3.D7.D3.D2.2D3.D3.D27.CA3.AC7.D3.D8.2D5.2D4.2D29.A3.C.A
6.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D27.2C2.A9.D3.D7.D3.D3.2D2.D3.D27.A2.C2.A7.D3.D
7.D3.D.D3.D.D$5.CA12.D5.D13.D.D5.D3.D21.A.A.3A7.D2.2D8.D.D3.D.D2.D3.D 28.2A2.A8.D2.2D11.D3.D3.D3.D27.C.A.A.C7.D2.2D9.D4.D.D3.D.D30.A3.2A6.D 2.2D7.D2.2D.D3.D.D2.2D26.C.C2A10.D2.2D7.D2.2D2.D.D2.D2.2D28.5A8.D2.2D 7.D2.2D5.D.D$5.A13.D5.D12.D2.4D3.4D20.A.2A4.A6.D.D.D7.D2.D2.D2.D3.4D
32.2A7.D.D.D10.D4.D4.4D29.A.A9.D.D.D9.D3.D2.D2.D2.D31.A10.D.D.D7.D.D.
D2.3D2.D.D.D26.C4.3A7.D.D.D7.D.D.D.D2.D2.D.D.D41.D.D.D7.D.D.D4.D3.3D$6.3A10.D5.D11.D3.D3.D5.D20.A4.2A.A6.2D2.D7.5D.5D5.D28.2A11.2D2.D9.D5. D7.D29.A.A9.2D2.D9.D3.5D.5D28.A.5A6.2D2.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.2D2.D27.C2A4.A 6.2D2.D7.2D2.D.5D.2D2.D28.5A8.2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D7.D$8.A10.D5.D10.D4.D3.D
5.D21.3A.A.A7.D3.D10.D5.D6.D29.A2.2A7.D3.D8.D6.D7.D28.CA.AC8.D3.D9.D
6.D5.D28.A.A4.A6.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D29.A.3A7.D3.D7.D3.D4.D2.D3.D27.A
2.C2.A7.D3.D7.D3.D2.D4.D3.D$18.3D3.3D4.D3.5D2.3D3.3D24.A.A10.3D4.D6.D 5.D3.3D30.A.A.A8.3D4.D3.5D2.3D3.3D43.3D4.D4.3D5.D5.D28.A.A.3A8.3D4.D 4.3D3.3D3.3D30.A.A10.3D4.D4.3D5.D3.3D27.A.A3.A.A7.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.3D$
76.2C68.A137.2A.A68.A65.2C5.2C10$73.A5.2A$74.A5.A$74.A5.A.2A$18.3D9.
3D3.3D4.D26.A3.A4.2A2.A4.3D11.D3.3D3.3D43.3D9.3D4.D6.D25.C17.3D10.D4.
3D2.5D28.C13.3D9.3D2.5D2.3D43.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D32.2C9.3D9.3D3.3D2.5D$17. D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D2.2D27.3A2.C4.2A4.D3.D9.2D2.D3.D.D3.D27.2A12.D3.D7.D3. D2.2D5.2D24.C.A2.CA11.D3.D8.2D3.D3.D5.D27.C.C.2A8.D3.D7.D3.D5.D.D3.D 29.A.A9.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D29.C2.A8.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D$21.D7.D3.D5.D
3.D32.2CACA6.D2.2D8.D.D6.D5.D27.A6.2A5.D2.2D11.D3.D4.D.D24.2A3.A.A10.
D2.2D9.D7.D4.D29.CA.A2.A6.D2.2D7.D2.2D4.D2.D3.D27.3A.3A7.D2.2D7.D2.2D
5.D.D3.D29.3A9.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D.D$6.2C11.2D9.4D4.D4.D30.2C4.A6.D.D.D7. D2.D4.2D5.D30.A5.A5.D.D.D10.D4.D3.D2.D31.A10.D.D.D9.D5.2D4.D32.A2.2A 6.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.D4.4D26.A7.A6.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.2D3.3D42.D.D.D7.D.D.D4.D 3.3D$6.AC13.D11.D3.D5.D31.C2.2A7.2D2.D7.5D5.D3.D27.4A.A.3A6.2D2.D9.D
5.D3.5D30.A.A3.2A3.2D2.D9.D7.D2.D31.2A11.2D2.D7.2D2.D2.D8.D27.3A.3A7.
2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D.D3.D29.3A9.2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D7.D$17.D3.D11.D2.D6.D31.A.A 9.D3.D10.D2.D3.D2.D28.A2.C.A.A8.D3.D8.D6.D6.D32.AC2.A.C3.D3.D9.D3.D3. D.D32.A4.2A6.D3.D7.D3.D.D9.D29.A.A9.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D29.C2.A8.D3.D 7.D3.D2.D4.D3.D$18.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.3D25.A2.A.C.A10.3D4.D6.D3.3D2.5D29.
C12.3D4.D3.5D2.3D5.D37.C5.3D4.D4.3D3.3D2.D34.A.A.A7.3D4.D4.3D2.D6.3D
43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D32.2C9.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.3D$70.4A.2A208.2A.2A$74.A$72.A.A$72.2A9$214.2A137.A.C.C.A68.2A.2A$3.2C.A12.D9.5D4.D3.3D43.3D11.
D3.3D3.3D33.C9.3D9.3D4.D6.D29.A.A.2A8.3D10.D4.3D2.5D29.2C2.A8.3D9.3D
2.5D4.D27.A.2A.2A.A7.3D9.3D3.3D2.5D33.A.2A5.3D9.3D3.3D4.D$3.2C.3A9.2D 13.D3.2D2.D3.D27.2A.A10.D3.D9.2D2.D3.D.D3.D29.A.A.A7.D3.D7.D3.D2.2D5. 2D31.A.A8.D3.D8.2D3.D3.D5.D28.A.C3A7.D3.D7.D3.D5.D3.2D27.A3.A3.A6.D3. D7.D3.D.D3.D5.D33.A7.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D2.2D$9.A9.D12.D3.D.D2.D2.2D28.A.
3A8.D2.2D8.D.D6.D.D2.2D27.3A.2A.A6.D2.2D11.D3.D4.D.D31.A.A8.D2.2D9.D
7.D4.D27.3A5.2A5.D2.2D7.D2.2D4.D3.D.D28.2A3.2A7.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D4.D31.
CA.A7.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D3.D$3.2A.2A.A9.D11.D3.D2.D2.D.D.D27.A5.A7.D.D.D 7.D2.D5.D2.D.D.D26.A7.A6.D.D.D10.D4.D3.D2.D29.CA2.AC7.D.D.D9.D6.D4.D 27.A3.5A2.A4.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.D3.D2.D30.3A9.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.2D4.D31.A2.A8. D.D.D7.D.D.D4.D4.D$4.A.2A.2A8.D10.D4.5D.2D2.D28.3A.A8.2D2.D7.5D3.D3.
2D2.D26.A.2A.3A7.2D2.D9.D5.D3.5D29.A.A9.2D2.D9.D5.D4.D29.3A5.2A5.2D2.
D7.2D2.D2.D4.5D27.2A3.2A7.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D2.D31.A.AC9.2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D
5.D$4.A14.D9.D8.D2.D3.D30.A.2A7.D3.D10.D3.D4.D3.D27.A.A.A9.D3.D8.D6.D 6.D30.A.A9.D3.D9.D4.D4.D32.A.C3A7.D3.D7.D3.D.D8.D27.A3.A3.A6.D3.D7.D 3.D.D3.D.D32.A12.D3.D7.D3.D2.D6.D$5.3A.2C7.3D4.D3.D8.D3.3D43.3D4.D6.D
2.5D2.3D29.C13.3D4.D3.5D2.3D5.D29.2A.A.A8.3D4.D4.3D2.5D.D33.2C2.A8.3D
4.D4.3D2.D8.D27.A.2A.2A.A7.3D4.D4.3D3.3D2.D29.2A.A13.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.
3D$7.A.2C207.2A133.A.C.C.A61.2A.2A10$10.2C206.2A$2.2A.2A2.C2.C205.A.A$.A.A.A4.C.C207.A64.C$.2A2.A5.C7.D10.3D3.3D3.3D25.2C16.3D11.D4.D4.3D 26.C2.C.C2.C8.3D9.3D3.3D2.5D33.CA.2A4.3D10.D4.3D3.3D26.C2.C.C2.C8.3D 9.3D3.3D5.D31.AC10.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D34.2A7.3D9.3D4.D4.3D$5.A.AC9.2D9.D3.
D.D3.D.D28.2A2.CA11.D3.D9.2D3.2D3.D3.D25.4A.4A7.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D40.A
4.D3.D8.2D3.D3.D.D3.D25.4A.4A7.D3.D7.D3.D.D7.2D28.A3.A9.D3.D7.D3.D.D
3.D.D3.D32.C.A6.D3.D7.D3.D2.2D3.D3.D$.5A2.A10.D13.D.D3.D.D32.A.A10.D 2.2D8.D.D4.D3.D2.2D29.A11.D2.2D11.D.D2.2D.D32.2C.4C.A4.D2.2D9.D7.D.D 2.2D29.A11.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D6.D.D28.4A3.C6.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D5.D32.A8.D2.2D 7.D2.2D3.D3.D3.D$.A4.A4.A7.D12.D3.3D2.4D31.A10.D.D.D7.D2.D4.D3.D.D.D
27.A3.3A7.D.D.D10.D2.D.D.D2.3D28.C.A.C3.A5.D.D.D9.D6.D2.D.D.D27.A2.4A
7.D.D.D7.D.D.D.4D2.D2.D32.4A6.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.2D4.2D31.A.A8.D.D.D7.D.D.
D3.D4.4D$4.A2.5A7.D11.D3.D3.D.D3.D30.A.A8.2D2.D7.5D3.D3.2D2.D27.4A2.A 7.2D2.D9.D3.2D2.D5.D27.A.C.C.2A6.2D2.D9.D5.D3.2D2.D27.3A3.A7.2D2.D7. 2D2.D.D3.D.5D27.4A10.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D5.D28.3A.A.A6.2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D7.D$
4.CA.A11.D10.D4.D3.D.D3.D31.AC2.2A4.D3.D10.D4.D3.D3.D31.A9.D3.D8.D4.D
3.D.D3.D25.3A.C.A.A7.D3.D9.D4.D4.D3.D31.A9.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D4.D28.C3.4A
6.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D27.A5.2A6.D3.D7.D3.D3.D7.D$.C5.A2.2A6.3D4.D3.5D 2.3D3.3D36.2C5.3D4.D6.D3.3D3.3D28.4A.4A6.3D4.D3.5D2.3D3.3D25.A3.A.C.A 2.A6.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.3D28.4A.4A6.3D4.D4.3D3.3D5.D31.A3.A7.3D4.D4.3D3. 3D3.3D28.2A13.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D$C.C4.A.A.A131.C2.C.C2.C58.2A2.A.A.A.
2A61.C2.C.C2.C64.CA$C2.C2.2A.2A204.2A.A68.C$.2C215.A$218.2A6$422.2A$422.2C$215.A211.2A$75.C2.C135.A.A209.A.A$18.3D8.5D2.3D3.3D30.4A9.3D9.
3D3.3D3.3D43.3D9.3D3.3D4.D28.A2.A2.A9.3D10.D5.D3.5D42.3D9.3D3.3D5.D
29.2C.2C9.3D9.3D3.3D4.D28.CA2.A11.3D9.3D4.D4.3D$17.D3.D11.D.D3.D.D30. A8.A5.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D45.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D2.2D28.2A.A.2A8.D3.D8.2D4.2D 3.D30.2C13.D3.D7.D3.D.D7.2D29.C3.C8.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D2.2D28.C.A.A10.D3. D7.D3.D2.2D3.D3.D$6.C10.D2.2D10.D2.D3.D.D30.10A5.D2.2D11.D.D3.D.D34.
2C9.D2.2D11.D.D2.2D3.D31.A3.2A6.D2.2D9.D5.D3.D30.A2.C.A9.D2.2D7.D2.2D
.D6.D.D30.3A9.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D3.D30.A.A.2C7.D2.2D7.D2.2D3.D7.D$5.C.C9. D.D.D9.D4.4D.4D42.D.D.D10.D3.3D2.4D30.C2.C8.D.D.D10.D2.D.D.D3.D28.2C. C.2A2.A5.D.D.D9.D5.D4.3D28.3A.3A7.D.D.D7.D.D.D.4D2.D2.D42.D.D.D7.D.D. D3.2D4.D30.A.A.A8.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.D6.D$6.CA9.2D2.D8.D8.D.D3.D26.10A5.2D
2.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D29.C.C9.2D2.D9.D3.2D2.D3.D28.2C.C2.A.A6.2D2.D9.D5.D
7.D30.A3.A6.2D2.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.5D29.3A9.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D3.D29.2C.A.A8.
2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D5.D$17.D3.D7.D9.D.D3.D26.A8.A5.D3.D8.D4.D3.D.D3.D30.C 10.D3.D8.D4.D3.D3.D32.CA2.2A5.D3.D9.D5.D3.D3.D27.2A.A2.2A6.D3.D7.D3.D .D3.D4.D29.C3.C8.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D32.A.A.C6.D3.D7.D3.D3.D4.D$18.3D4.
D3.D6.3D3.3D30.4A9.3D4.D3.5D2.3D3.3D43.3D4.D3.5D2.3D3.3D32.A.A8.3D4.D
4.3D3.3D3.3D28.A.A12.3D4.D4.3D3.3D5.D29.2C.2C9.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D31.A
2.AC7.3D4.D4.3D3.3D2.5D$75.C2.C138.A.A204.A.A$218.A205.2A$429.2C$429.
2A9$81.2A200.2A3.2A$4.2C.C10.3D8.5D2.3D4.D32.2C.C2.A5.3D9.3D2.5D3.D
31.2A11.3D10.D4.3D3.3D43.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D28.2C3.2C8.3D9.3D2.5D2.3D43.3D
9.3D3.3D3.3D43.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D$5.A.3A7.D3.D11.D.D3.D2.2D31.C.C.3A5.D3. D7.D3.D5.D2.2D30.A2.A.2A6.D3.D8.2D3.D3.D.D3.D29.AC10.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D. D3.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D 3.D$3.A.A4.A6.D2.2D10.D2.D3.D3.D26.2A3.C.C9.D2.2D11.D4.D4.D31.A.A.A7.
D2.2D9.D3.D3.D5.D29.2C10.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D3.D.D3.D41.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D5.D3.
D29.2C10.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D.D2.2D30.2C9.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D2.2D.D3.D$2.A.2A. 2A.A6.D.D.D9.D4.4D3.D26.A2.C.A.3A7.D.D.D10.D4.D5.D28.2C2A.A3.C5.D.D.D 9.D4.4D3.2D42.D.D.D7.D.D.D2.4D2.4D27.CA3.AC7.D.D.D7.D.D.D2.3D3.4D29.C .C9.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.2D2.D.D.D29.C2.C8.D.D.D7.D.D.D.D.D.D2.3D$2.A4.A.A7.
2D2.D8.D8.D3.D27.4A.A3.A6.2D2.D9.D4.D6.D28.C3.A.2A2C5.2D2.D9.D7.D5.D
41.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D5.D27.C.A.A.C7.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D5.D30.CA9.2D2.D7.2D2.
D5.D.2D2.D29.C2.C8.2D2.D7.2D2.D.2D2.D.D3.D$3.3A.A9.D3.D7.D9.D3.D32.A 2.2A6.D3.D8.D4.D7.D30.A.A.A8.D3.D9.D7.D.D3.D30.2C9.D3.D7.D3.D5.D5.D 29.A.A9.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D5.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D30.2C9.D3.D7.D3.D.D 3.D.D3.D$5.C.2C9.3D4.D3.D6.3D3.3D28.A.A12.3D4.D3.5D.D6.3D28.2A.A2.A8.
3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D31.CA10.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D30.A.A10.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D
43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D$73.2A72.2A135.CA.AC11$10.2A
344.CA.2A$10.C.C344.A.A.A$11.2C5.3D8.5D2.3D3.3D30.A.2A9.3D9.3D2.5D2.
3D43.3D10.D4.3D3.3D43.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D43.3D9.3D2.5D2.3D32.A2.2A6.3D9.3D
3.3D3.3D$7.AC8.D3.D7.D5.D5.D3.D29.2A.A8.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D41.D3.D8.2D 3.D3.D.D3.D29.C2.C8.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D28.2C.A 9.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$6.A.A8.D2.2D7.D5.D5.D3.D27.2A12.D2.2D11.D.D5.D
3.D30.2C9.D2.2D9.D3.D3.D5.D29.4A8.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D3.D.D3.D30.C10.D2.2D
7.D2.2D.D5.D3.D28.C2.5A5.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D.D2.2D$6.A10.D.D.D8.3D2.4D3. 4D26.A3.2A9.D.D.D10.D3.3D3.4D29.C2.C8.D.D.D9.D4.3D5.D42.D.D.D7.D.D.D 2.4D2.4D29.C.C9.D.D.D7.D.D.D2.3D3.3D26.C4.A4.C5.D.D.D7.D.D.D3.2D2.D.D .D$4.A.A10.2D2.D11.D.D3.D5.D26.4A.3A7.2D2.D9.D7.D5.D30.2C9.2D2.D9.D3.
D3.D3.D31.4A8.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D5.D30.2C9.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D.D3.D25.5A2.C8.
2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D.2D2.D$4.CA11.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D5.D34.A6.D3.D8.D4.D3.D5.D 41.D3.D9.D3.D3.D2.D32.C2.C8.D3.D7.D3.D5.D5.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D 29.A.2C8.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$2C16.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D29.2C.3A8.3D4.D3.
5D2.3D3.3D43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D2.5D42.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.
3D26.2A2.A12.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D$C.C71.2C.A273.A.A.A$.2A349.2A.AC11$75. A70.2A.2A$18.3D8.5D2.3D4.D30.A.A11.3D9.3D2.5D.5D31.A.A8.3D10.D4.3D4.D
35.2C7.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D33.C9.3D9.3D2.5D2.3D26.A16.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D$17.D3. D7.D5.D6.2D29.A.A2.A8.D3.D7.D3.D.D9.D31.A.A7.D3.D8.2D3.D3.D2.2D33.A2. C6.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D33.A.A.A.CA4.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D25.3A13.D3.D7.D3.D .D3.D.D3.D$6.A10.D2.2D7.D5.D7.D27.3A2.2A.C7.D2.2D11.D.D8.D29.CA.A.2A
6.D2.2D9.D3.D3.D3.D32.A.AC7.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D3.D.D32.A.2A.A.2A4.D2.2D7.D
2.2D.D5.D3.D28.A3.2A7.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D.D3.D$5.A.C9.D.D.D8.3D2.4D4.D26. A3.2A3.C2.CA3.D.D.D10.D3.3D4.D28.C2.A.A2.C6.D.D.D9.D4.3D4.D32.A10.D.D .D7.D.D.D2.4D.4D29.A4.A7.D.D.D7.D.D.D2.3D3.3D28.AC4.A7.D.D.D7.D.D.D4. D3.4D$6.C10.2D2.D11.D.D3.D3.D27.3A2.2AC3.CA3.2D2.D9.D7.D2.D29.2A.A.AC
8.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D3.D29.CA.A10.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D.D3.D25.2A.A.2A.A7.2D2.D
7.2D2.D5.D.D3.D33.A.2A4.2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D7.D$17.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D29.A. A11.D3.D8.D4.D3.D.D31.A.A11.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D28.C2.A11.D3.D7.D3.D5.D.D 3.D25.AC.A.A.A8.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D30.CA.A.A5.D3.D7.D3.D2.D8.D$18.3D
4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D29.C.C11.3D4.D3.5D2.3D2.D31.A.A12.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D27.
2C14.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D30.C12.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D30.C.A.A.A6.3D4.D4.3D2.
5D2.3D$75.C66.2A.2A208.2C3.A11$11.2A342.C$6.2C.C2.A205.2A134.A.C$5.C.
C.3A6.3D8.5D2.3D4.D31.2C.A.2A6.3D9.3D2.5D3.D44.3D10.D4.3D2.5D30.A2.A
8.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D43.3D9.3D2.5D2.3D29.A.C11.3D9.3D3.3D2.5D$5.A.C9.D3.D 7.D5.D3.D2.2D28.A.C.A.2A.A5.D3.D7.D3.D.D6.2D43.D3.D8.2D3.D5.D31.C2.2A 9.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D29.A3.C7.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D5. D$3.C2A.5A5.D2.2D7.D9.D3.D27.A.2A.A10.D2.2D11.D.D7.D43.D2.2D9.D3.D5.D
30.A.A.A10.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D3.D5.D30.C10.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D9.D30.4A7.D2.2D7.
D2.2D5.D4.D$2.C3.A4.A5.D.D.D8.3D5.D4.D27.A3.2A10.D.D.D10.D3.3D4.D32. 2C9.D.D.D9.D3.4D3.3D27.2A2.A2.2A6.D.D.D7.D.D.D2.4D3.2D30.C.C9.D.D.D7. D.D.D2.3D5.D42.D.D.D7.D.D.D4.D4.D$2.3CA2.A8.2D2.D11.D3.D5.D28.2A13.2D
2.D9.D7.D3.D32.2C9.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D5.D30.A.A.A6.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D5.D30.C
10.2D2.D7.2D2.D5.D3.D32.4A7.2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D4.D$5.A.2A8.D3.D7.D3.D2.D 6.D30.2A.A9.D3.D8.D4.D3.D3.D43.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D29.2A2.C7.D3.D7.D3.D 5.D.D3.D41.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D2.D32.A3.C7.D3.D7.D3.D2.D4.D$2.CA.A12.3D4.D
4.3D2.5D2.3D29.A.2A10.3D4.D3.5D2.3D3.3D43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D28.A2.A11.
3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D2.5D28.A.C11.3D4.D4.3D2.5D.D$3.A.A 207.2A139.A.C$.A.A.2A348.C$.2A7$79.2A$79.2C2$9.2C$7.C2.A7.3D8.5D2.3D 3.3D33.C9.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D43.3D10.D4.3D4.D44.3D9.3D3.3D3.3D28.2C3.2C8. 3D9.3D2.5D2.3D43.3D9.3D3.3D2.5D$7.3A7.D3.D7.D5.D3.D.D3.D31.A.C7.D3.D
7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D29.A.A.A7.D3.D8.2D3.D6.2D34.C8.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D
27.A2.C2.A7.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D29.2C10.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D$4.C12.D2.2D7. D9.D.D2.2D32.A8.D2.2D11.D5.D5.D27.3A.2A.A6.D2.2D9.D3.D7.D33.C.C7.D2. 2D7.D2.2D.D3.D.D3.D28.5A8.D2.2D7.D2.2D.D9.D28.A2.A9.D2.2D7.D2.2D5.D.D$4.6A7.D.D.D8.3D5.D2.D.D.D29.3A9.D.D.D10.D5.D4.2D27.A7.A6.D.D.D9.D3.
4D4.D32.A.A8.D.D.D7.D.D.D2.3D3.3D42.D.D.D7.D.D.D2.3D5.D30.2A.A8.D.D.D
7.D.D.D4.D3.3D$9.C7.2D2.D11.D3.D3.2D2.D28.A12.2D2.D9.D5.D7.D26.A.2A. 3A7.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D3.D30.3A.A.A6.2D2.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D28.5A8.2D2.D7. 2D2.D5.D3.D34.A8.2D2.D7.2D2.D3.D7.D$4.3A10.D3.D7.D3.D2.D4.D3.D27.C.A
11.D3.D8.D5.D4.D3.D27.A.A.A9.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D29.A5.2A6.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.
D.D3.D27.A2.C2.A7.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D2.D35.2A7.D3.D7.D3.D2.D4.D3.D$3.A2.C 11.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.3D29.C13.3D4.D3.5D.5D2.3D43.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D28.2A 13.3D4.D4.3D3.3D3.3D28.2C3.2C8.3D4.D4.3D3.3D2.5D42.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.3D$
3.2C2$72.2C$72.2A!
The search is run by perturbing the catalysts in the following list one by one.
The search counts the results not shown in the preceding catalysts.
(e.g. it counts the block_eater catalyses not exhibited by the spartan catalysts.)

Code: Select all

x = 193, y = 1314, rule = LifeHistory
2C18.D6.2D15.D$AC18.D7.D15.D$20.4D4.D4.3D3.4D.D2.D$20.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D 5.D.D$20.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.3D$20.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D2.D$20.4D4.2D3.3D3.
4D.D3.D14$AC42.D6.2D15.D$2C20.D21.D7.D15.D$20.5D.D3.D2.3D8.4D4.D4.3D 3.4D.D2.D3.4D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D.D3.D$.2C19.D3.D.D.D .D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.3D4.3D$.CA19.D3.2D.2D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.
D2.D6.D$23.2D.D3.D2.3D2.5D.4D4.2D3.3D3.4D.D3.D.4D14$2C60.D6.2D15.D$2C 20.D39.D7.D15.D$20.5D.D.2D3.4D.4D3.4D.4D8.4D4.D4.3D3.4D.D2.D$22.D3.2D 2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D2.3D2.D
3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.3D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D5.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D 5.D2.D$23.2D.D6.4D.D3.D.4D2.4D2.5D.4D4.2D3.3D3.4D.D3.D$50.D$50.D12$. 2C60.2D17.2D$C2.C18.D41.D16.D2.D$C.C17.5D.D.2D3.4D.4D3.4D.4D10.D4.3D 3.4D2.D$.C20.D3.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.3D$22.D3.D5.D3. D.D3.D2.3D2.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D2.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D5.D.D3.D9.D3.D3.D
.D3.D2.D$23.2D.D6.4D.D3.D.4D2.4D2.5D3.2D3.3D3.4D2.D$50.D$50.D12$.C18.
D$C.C17.D19.D$.CA17.4D3.3D3.4D.5D$20.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D$20.D3.D.D3.D.D
3.D3.D$20.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D$20.4D3.3D3.4D4.2D14$.C60.D$C.C19.D39.D19.
D$.2C17.5D.D.2D3.4D.4D3.4D.4D8.4D3.3D3.4D.5D$22.D3.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D
5.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D2.3D2.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3. D3.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D5.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D$23.2D.D6.4D.D3.D. 4D2.4D2.5D.4D3.3D3.4D4.2D$50.D$50.D12$2C24.D$C.C23.D7.D$.CA18.4D.D.2D
8.4D$20.D5.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D$21.3D2.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$24.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$20.
4D2.D3.D3.2D2.4D$38.D$38.D12$.A30.D$A.C19.D9.D$.C18.5D.D3.D.4D$22.D3.
D3.D.D3.D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D$23.2D2.4D.4D14$.C72.D$C.C 19.D41.D9.D$.C18.5D.D.2D3.4D.4D3.4D.4D8.5D.D3.D.4D$22.D3.2D2.D.D3.D.D 3.D.D5.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D2.3D2.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D5.D.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D$23.2D.D6.4D.D3.D.4D2.4D2.5D
4.2D2.4D.4D$50.D$50.D12$.2C59.D$C2.C18.D39.D7.D$.2C17.5D.D.2D3.4D.4D 3.4D.4D8.D.2D8.D3.D2.3D$22.D3.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D3.D7.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D
.D3.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D2.3D2.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.5D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D
3.D5.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D4.D.D2.D$23.2D.D6.4D.D3.D.4D2.4D2.5D.D3.D3.2D4.D 4.4D$50.D$50.D12$.2C81.D$C2.C18.D61.D$C2.C16.5D.D.2D3.4D.4D3.4D.4D8.
4D3.3D2.4D3.4D$.2C19.D3.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$
22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D2.3D2.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$22.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D 5.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$23.2D.D6.4D.D3.D.4D2.4D2.5D.4D3.3D2.D3.
D2.4D$50.D11.D$50.D11.D12$CA$A33.D$.3A17.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$3.A16.D
3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$20.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$20.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$21.4D 2.4D4.2D2.4D.D14$2C18.D6.2D15.D$2A2.CA14.D7.D15.D25.D$4.A.A13.4D4.D4.
3D3.4D.D2.D9.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$6.A13.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D.D9.D3.D.D3. D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$6.A.A11.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.3D9.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$7.AC2. 2A7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D2.D8.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$11.2C7.4D4.2D3.3D3.4D.D3.
D.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D14$.C18.D$C.A2.CA13.D19.D23.D$2A3.A.A12.4D3.3D 3.4D.5D8.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$7.A12.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D9.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D
3.D.2D2.D$7.A.A3.2A5.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D9.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$8.AC2.A.C5.D
3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D9.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$13.C6.4D3.3D3.4D4.2D.5D2.4D2.4D4. 2D2.4D.D14$10.2A14.D$10.C.C13.D7.D29.D$11.2C8.4D.D.2D8.4D9.3D3.4D.5D
2.3D2.D.2D$7.AC11.D5.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$6.A.A
12.3D2.D3.D3.D3.D3.D7.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$6.A17.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D7.D5.D3.D 3.D3.D5.D$4.A.A13.4D2.D3.D3.2D2.4D2.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D$4.CA32.D$2C
36.D$C.C$.2A10$2A.A16.D17.D29.D30.2D$.A.3A14.D17.D19.D5.D3.D13.D11.D
5.D$A5.A13.D.2D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D8.D3.D7.5D.D.2D8.5D2.4D9.D$.3A.A14.2D2.D
.D3.D.D3.D.D.D9.D3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$3.A.2A13.D3.D.D3.D.D 3.D.3D9.D.D.D3.D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$20.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D8.2D.
2D3.D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$20.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.D3.D.5D.D3.D3.2D5.2D.D 3.D.5D4.2D2.4D3.2D4.2D14$3.A17.2D27.D17.D29.D30.2D$A.A.A17.D27.D17.D 19.D5.D3.D13.D11.D5.D$2A2.A17.D4.3D2.4D3.3D8.D.2D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D8.D3.D
7.5D.D.2D8.5D2.4D9.D$4.2A16.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D9.D 3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$2A20.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.
D.3D9.D.D.D3.D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$.A2.2A16.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D 3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D8.2D.2D3.D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$.A.A.A16.2D3.3D
2.D3.D2.4D.5D.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.D3.D.5D.D3.D3.2D5.2D.D3.D.5D4.2D2.4D3.2D
4.2D$2.A39.D$39.3D12$7.2A$7.2C13.D11.D5.D$20.5D.D3.D7.5D$22.D3.D3.D3.
D5.D$6.C15.D3.D.D.D3.D5.D$5.A.C14.D3.2D.2D3.D5.D$6.A16.2D.D3.D3.2D5. 2D$3.3A$2.A$.C.A$2.C3$2C$2A6$.2C17.D47.D30.2D$A2.A16.D7.D29.D5.D3.D 13.D11.D5.D$.2A.A15.D.2D8.D3.D2.3D8.D3.D7.5D.D.2D8.5D2.4D9.D$4.A15.2D 2.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$4.2A14.D3.D3.D3.D
3.D.5D7.D.D.D3.D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$20.D3.D3.D4.D.D2.D11.2D.2D3. D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$20.D3.D3.2D4.D4.4D.5D.D3.D3.2D5.2D.D3.D.5D
4.2D2.4D3.2D4.2D14$C2.C28.D6.2D$4A18.D9.D7.D$20.5D2.4D.4D4.D4.3D$4A
18.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$C2.C18.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.
D3.D$23.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3.4D14$3.A.A69.2D29.D$.3A.3A62.D5.D28.2D$A7.A12.
D.D3.3D3.3D3.4D2.3D9.4D.4D2.5D3.D4.3D2.D.2D3.4D9.D$.3A.3A12.D.D.D.D3. D.D3.D.D5.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D5.D3.D3.D.2D2.D.D5.5D3.D$3.A.A14.D.D.D.D
3.D.D3.D2.3D2.5D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D5.D3.5D.D6.3D10.D$20.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D5.D. D11.D3.D.D3.D3.D5.D3.D5.D9.D9.D$20.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.4D3.4D.5D2.4D.D3.D4.
2D3.2D3.4D.D5.4D9.3D14$2.2C16.D17.D21.D$C2.A16.D17.D21.D$3A17.4D3.3D 3.3D2.D2.D3.3D2.4D3.4D$20.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$3A17.D3. D.D3.D.D3.D.3D3.5D.D3.D.D3.D$C2.A16.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D2.D5.D3.D.D3.D
$2.2C16.4D3.3D3.3D2.D3.D2.4D.D3.D2.4D14$2C.2C19.D17.D31.D30.2D$C3.C 19.D17.D31.D25.D5.D$.3A17.4D2.3D3.4D2.4D8.4D.4D3.4D.D.2D2.D2.D9.4D2.
3D10.D$20.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D5.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D.D.D9.D5.D3.D3.D5.D$
.3A16.D3.D.5D.D3.D.D3.D8.3D2.D3.D.D3.D.D5.3D9.D5.D3.D3.D5.D$C3.C15.D 3.D.D5.D3.D.D3.D11.D.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D2.D8.D5.D3.D3.D5.D$2C.2C16.4D2.4D
2.4D2.4D.5D.4D2.4D3.4D.D5.D3.D.5D2.4D2.3D4.2D4.2D$56.D$56.D12$7.2C25. 2D3.2D39.D17.D$5.A2.C24.D2.D3.D17.D21.D17.D$4.A.AC12.D.2D3.3D3.D6.D4. 3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D8.D.2D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D$4.A15.2D2.D.D3.D.3D5.D3.D3.D.
D7.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D$.CA.A15.D5.5D2.D6.D3.5D.D7.D3.D 3.D.D11.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.3D$C2.A16.D5.D6.D6.D3.D5.D7.D3.D3.D.D11.D3.D.D
3.D.D3.D.D2.D$2C18.D6.4D2.D6.2D3.4D2.4D4.2D2.3D2.D5.5D.D3.D2.3D3.3D2. D3.D14$3.2C19.D14.2D$3.A.A18.D15.D23.D$.A.A.3A13.4D.D3.D2.4D3.D10.3D
3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$A.2A4.A11.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D9.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D 2.D$A4.2A.A11.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D9.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$.3A.A.A12.D3.D.D3.D .D3.D3.D9.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$3.A.A15.4D2.4D2.4D3.2D2.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D
.D$4.2C13$2C3.2C14.2D31.D13.D$A2.C2.A15.D31.D13.D$.5A16.D4.3D2.4D3.3D
9.4D2.3D3.4D.D2.D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D.D$.5A16.D3.D3.
D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D5.3D$A2.C2.A15.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D 5.D2.D$2C3.2C15.2D3.3D2.D3.D2.4D.5D2.4D2.3D3.4D.D3.D$42.D$39.3D12$.C 18.D17.D47.D12.2D28.2D$A.C17.D17.D7.D29.D5.D3.D13.D29.D$A.C17.4D3.3D 3.3D2.D.2D8.D3.D2.3D8.D3.D7.5D.D.2D10.D4.3D2.4D3.3D10.D4.3D3.3D$.A3.C
14.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.
D.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D$2.4A14.D3.D.5D.5D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.5D7.D.D.D3.D5.D 3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D9.D3.5D.D3.D$20.D3.D.D5.D5.D3.D3.D4.D.D2.D
11.2D.2D3.D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D9.D3.D5.D3.D$2.4A14.4D3.4D2.4D .D3.D3.2D4.D4.4D.5D.D3.D3.2D5.2D.D3.D.5D3.2D3.3D2.D3.D2.4D.5D3.2D3.4D 2.4D$.A3.C114.D23.D$A.C114.3D21.3D$A.C$.C10$CA3.AC14.2D27.D17.D$C.A.A .C15.D27.D17.D$2.A.A17.D4.3D2.4D3.3D8.D.2D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D$2.A.A17.D3.D 3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D$.CA.AC16.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D
3.D.D3.D.3D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D$22.2D3.3D2.D3.D
2.4D.5D.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.D3.D$42.D$39.3D12$2A3.2A14.2D27.D17.D27.D7.D6. 2D15.D$2C3.2C15.D27.D17.D27.D7.D7.D15.D$22.D4.3D2.4D3.3D8.D.2D3.3D3. 3D2.D2.D9.4D.4D3.4D7.4D4.D4.3D3.4D.D2.D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.2D2.D.D
3.D.D3.D.D.D9.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D.D$CA3.AC15.D3.D3.D.D 3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.3D9.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.3D$C.A.
A.C15.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D8.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D
3.D3.D.D5.D2.D$2.A.A17.2D3.3D2.D3.D2.4D.5D.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.D3.D.5D2.4D. D3.D2.4D.5D.4D4.2D3.3D3.4D.D3.D$2.A.A37.D$.CA.AC33.3D12$6.2A70.D13.D$5.C.A26.D43.D13.D$5.A15.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D9.3D2.4D9.4D2.3D3.4D.D2.D$3.A.A14.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D.D$.3A.A.A
12.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D11.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D5.3D$A5.2A12.D5.D3.D3.D3. D5.D11.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D2.D$2A19.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D2.3D2.D
3.D.5D2.4D2.3D3.4D.D3.D14$7.2A.2A8.D$8.A.2A8.D25.D$8.A11.D.2D2.D3.D.D .2D2.D.2D9.4D2.4D.4D3.3D$5.CA.A11.2D2.D.D3.D.2D2.D.2D2.D3.D3.D5.D3.D.
D3.D.D3.D$4.A2.A12.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D7.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D.5D$3.A.AC13.D3.D.D
3.D.D5.D7.D3.D5.D3.D.D3.D.D$3.A16.D3.D2.4D.D5.D7.2D3.4D2.4D.D3.D2.4D$
2A.A$2A.2A12$6.2A24.D6.2D129.D$4.A2.A14.D9.D7.D23.D65.D39.D19.D$.C2.
2A14.5D2.4D.4D4.D4.3D9.4D8.4D2.D.D3.3D3.4D2.3D9.4D2.4D.D.2D2.D.2D9.3D
2.D.2D9.3D2.4D8.4D3.3D3.4D.5D$A.A.A17.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D7.D7.D3.D 3.D.D.D.D.D3.D.D5.D3.D7.D5.D3.D.2D2.D.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D 7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D$2A2.A2.2A13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D8.3D4.D3.D3.D.D.D.
D.5D2.3D2.5D7.D5.D3.D.D5.D7.D3.5D.D11.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D$4. A.A.A13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D15.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D9.D.D11.D5.D3.D.D5.D7.D 3.D5.D11.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D$3.2A2.C15.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3.4D.5D.
4D4.2D3.4D.D3.D2.4D.4D3.4D.5D2.4D2.4D.D5.D7.2D3.4D.D5.5D2.3D2.D3.D.5D
.4D3.3D3.4D4.2D$.A2.A$.2A12$2C5.2C$A.A3.A.A31.D41.D$.A2.C2.A13.4D2.3D 2.4D2.5D.D3.D.D.2D2.D3.D8.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$2.5A13.D5.D3.D.D3.D3.D
3.D3.D.2D2.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$20.D5.5D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D 5.D3.D7.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$2.5A13.D5.D5.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D3.D7.D5.D3.D
3.D3.D5.D$.A2.C2.A13.4D2.4D.D3.D4.2D2.4D.D6.4D.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D$A
.A3.A.A51.D$2C5.2C48.3D12$7.C12.D57.D$4.A.A.A.CA8.D13.D17.D25.D$3.A.
2A.A.2A8.D.2D8.5D2.3D8.5D2.3D3.4D.D.2D3.4D.D.2D3.3D2.4D$3.A4.A11.2D2. D9.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D.D3.D.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D$2A.A.2A.A11.D3.D
9.D3.D3.D9.D3.5D.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D3.D$AC.A.A.A12.D3.D9.D3.D3.D9. D3.D5.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D3.D$4.C15.D3.D.5D4.2D2.3D2.5D4.2D2.4D2.4D
.D6.4D.D6.3D2.4D$92.D$92.D12$2C.A47.3D$2C.3A28.D15.D3.D$6.A14.3D3.4D. 5D2.3D2.D.2D6.D$2A.2A.A13.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D4.D$.A.2A.2A12.5D.D 3.D3.D3.5D.D7.D$.A18.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D6.D$2.3A.2C13.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5. 5D$4.A.2C13$6.2C12.D17.D21.D41.D26.2D$4.C2.A12.D17.D21.D41.D15.D11.D$4.3A13.4D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D3.3D2.4D3.4D8.3D2.4D8.4D3.3D3.4D2.3D3.4D.5D2. 4D3.D$.C18.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D
3.D.D3.D.D7.D3.D3.D3.D$.6A13.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.3D3.5D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D 3.D7.D3.D.5D.D3.D.5D2.3D4.D3.D3.D3.D$6.C13.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D2.D5.D
3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D9.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$.3A16.4D3.3D3.3D2. D3.D2.4D.D3.D2.4D.5D2.3D2.D3.D.5D.4D3.4D2.4D2.4D.4D5.2D2.4D3.2D$A2.C
82.D$2C84.D12$3.AC69.D27.D26.2D$A3.A29.D29.D5.D3.D27.D15.D11.D$4A3.C
13.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D8.D3.D7.5D.D.2D8.4D3.3D3.4D2.3D3.4D.5D2.4D3.D$4.4A12.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D 3.D.D7.D3.D3.D3.D$4A16.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D11.D.D.D3.D5.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.5D.
D3.D.5D2.3D4.D3.D3.D3.D$C3.4A12.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D11.2D.2D3.D5.D3.D3.D 7.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D9.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$3.A3.A13.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D.D3.D3.
2D5.2D.D3.D.5D.4D3.4D2.4D2.4D.4D5.2D2.4D3.2D$3.CA81.D$86.D12$3.C2.C 25.D6.2D34.2D43.D26.2D$3.4A15.D9.D7.D35.D43.D15.D11.D$A8.A10.5D2.4D. 4D4.D4.3D9.3D2.4D10.D4.3D2.4D3.3D8.4D3.3D3.4D2.3D3.4D.5D2.4D3.D$10A
12.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.
D.D3.D.D7.D3.D3.D3.D$22.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D7.D3.D.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D. D3.D7.D3.D.5D.D3.D.5D2.3D4.D3.D3.D3.D$10A12.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D11.D3.D
.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D9.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$A8.A13.2D2.4D .4D4.2D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D3.D.5D3.2D3.3D2.D3.D2.4D.5D.4D3.4D2.4D2.4D.4D5. 2D2.4D3.2D$3.4A89.D7.D$3.C2.C86.3D8.D12$3.A.A.A48.D17.D29.D30.2D$.3A. 2A.A25.D21.D17.D19.D5.D3.D13.D11.D5.D$A7.A12.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D8.D.
2D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D8.D3.D7.5D.D.2D8.5D2.4D9.D$A.2A.3A12.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D 3.D.2D2.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D9.D3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$.A.A
.A14.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D11.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.3D9.D.D.D3.D5.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D
3.D5.D$20.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D11.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D8.2D.2D3.D5.D3.D3.D9. D3.D3.D3.D5.D$21.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.D3.D.5D.D3.D3.2D
5.2D.D3.D.5D4.2D2.4D3.2D4.2D14$6.C$3.A.A.A50.D$.3A.2A.A12.3D3.3D2.D3. D.D.2D3.D.D3.3D2.5D$A7.A11.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D.D.D.D.D3.D3.D$A.2A.3A 12.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D.D.D.5D3.D$.A.A.A14.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D7.D
$2.C18.4D2.3D3.4D.D5.D3.D2.4D4.2D$24.D$21.3D12$5.CA.2A41.3D14.D12.2D$6.A.A.A23.D15.D3.D13.D13.D11.D$6.A2.2A10.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D6.D8.4D.D
2.D3.3D4.D4.3D2.5D2.3D2.4D$3.2C.A13.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D3.2D8.D5. D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D$3.C2.5A9.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D9.D8.3D2.3D
3.5D3.D3.5D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D$C4.A4.C9.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D5.D3.D11.D.D2.D2.D 7.D3.D7.D3.D3.D.D3.D$5A2.C13.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D6.3D2.5D.4D2.D3.D2.4D3.
2D3.4D4.2D2.3D2.D3.D$4.A.2C$2A2.A$A.A.A$.2A.AC10$2A66.D6.2D$A.A.2A28.
D23.D9.D7.D$2.A.A16.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D8.5D2.4D.4D4.D4.3D$2.A.A15.D3.
D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$CA2.AC14.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D. D13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D$.A.A16.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D$.A.A17.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D4.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3.4D$2A.A.A$4.2A12$5.C62.D
29.D11.D17.D$4.C.C27.D23.D9.D19.D5.D3.D11.D17.D$3.A.A15.3D3.4D.5D2.3D
2.D.2D8.5D.D3.D.4D8.D3.D7.5D.D.2D8.D.2D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D$.3A.A.A12.D3.D. D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D .D.D$A5.2A12.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D13.D3.D3.D.D3.D7.D.D.D3.D5.D3.D3.D7.D3.D
.D3.D.D3.D.3D$2A18.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D13.D3.D3.D.D3.D7.2D.2D3.D5.D3.D3.D 7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D$21.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D4.2D2.4D.4D2.5D.D3.D3.2D
5.2D.D3.D.5D.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.D3.D14$3.2A15.D$2.A2.A.2A11.D$3.A.A.A12.D 2.D3.4D.5D.D3.D2.4D.4D$2C2A.A3.C10.D.D3.D3.D4.D2.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$C3.A. 2A2C10.3D3.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$2.A.A.A13.D2.D2.D3.D2.D4.D3.D.D3.D
.D3.D$.2A.A2.A12.D3.D2.4D.5D2.4D2.4D.D3.D$5.2A35.D$39.3D12$.C30.D$C.C .2A22.D3.D$.CA.A2.A13.D.D8.D2.D3.3D2.4D$3.A2.2A12.D.D.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D .D3.D$.2A17.D.D.D3.D3.3D3.5D.D3.D$.A4.2A12.D3.D3.D3.D2.D2.D5.D3.D$3.A
.A.A12.D3.D3.2D2.D3.D2.4D.4D$2.2A.2A37.D$44.D12$.2A3.C43.5D$.A3.C.A
26.D15.D$2.A3.2A13.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D2.D$3.A16.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D
2.D2.3D$.A.5A12.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D9.D$A.A4.A12.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D5.D3.D$A .A.3A14.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D6.3D$.2A.A13$2.2A16.D89.D6.2D$2.A6.2A9.D7.D
29.D41.D9.D7.D47.D$4.A5.A9.D.2D8.D3.D2.3D9.4D8.4D2.D.D3.3D3.4D2.3D8. 5D2.4D.4D4.D4.3D9.3D2.4D9.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$4A.A.3A10.2D2.D3.D3.D3.
D.D3.D7.D7.D3.D3.D.D.D.D.D3.D.D5.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.D
3.D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$A2.C.A.A12.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.5D8.3D4.D3.D3. D.D.D.D.5D2.3D2.5D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D7.D3.D.D3.D7.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$
4.C15.D3.D3.D4.D.D2.D15.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D9.D.D13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D
11.D3.D.D3.D7.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$20.D3.D3.2D4.D4.4D.5D.4D4.2D3.4D.D3.D 2.4D.4D3.4D.5D4.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D3.D.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D 14$A25.D$3A23.D7.D29.D41.D17.D$3.A3.2A12.4D.D.2D8.4D9.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.
D.2D8.D3.D2.4D.D.2D9.4D.4D2.5D$2.AC4.A11.D5.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D 3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D$8.A.2A9.3D2.D3.D3.D
3.D3.D7.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D11.D3.D.D3.D.D7.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D$5.CA.A.A13.D. D3.D3.D3.D3.D7.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D12.D.D2.D3.D.D7.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D$4.C.A.
A.A9.4D2.D3.D3.2D2.4D2.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D3.D4.4D.D7.2D3.4D.D3.D
4.2D$4.2C3.A28.D$38.D12$4.2C2.A23.D$3.A.C3A23.D$.3A5.2A10.4D2.3D2.D2. D2.D3.D2.3D$A3.5A2.A8.D5.D3.D.D.D3.D3.D.D3.D$.3A5.2A10.3D2.D3.D.3D3.D .D.D.5D$3.A.C3A15.D.D3.D.D2.D2.2D.2D.D$4.2C2.A11.4D3.3D2.D3.D.D3.D2. 4D14$10.2C39.3D$2.2A.2A2.C2.C21.D15.D3.D$.A.A.A4.C.C8.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.
D.2D6.D$.2A2.A5.C8.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D3.2D$5.A.AC11.5D.D3.D3.D3.
5D.D9.D$.5A2.A11.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D5.D3.D$.A4.A4.A9.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D6.
3D$4.A2.5A$4.CA.A$.C5.A2.2A$C.C4.A.A.A$C2.C2.2A.2A$.2C8$2.2C.C14.4D2. 5D2.3D$3.A.3A12.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$.A.A4.A11.D3.D3.D3.D$A.2A.2A.A11.4D4.D
4.3D$A4.A.A12.D3.D3.D7.D$.3A.A14.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$3.C.2C13.4D4.D4.3D14$.
A.C.C.A19.2D3.D$A.2A.2A.A19.D3.D$A3.A3.A12.3D4.D3.D2.D$.2A3.2A12.D3.D 3.D3.D.D$3.3A14.5D3.D3.3D$.2A3.2A12.D7.D3.D2.D$A3.A3.A12.4D3.2D2.D3.D
$A.2A.2A.A$.A.C.C.A12$3.A20.D15.2D24.D14.2D$2.A.A19.D9.D4.D2.D3.D19.D
15.D23.D$A2.A2.A14.4D.D.2D9.D4.5D.D3.D8.4D.D3.D2.4D3.D10.3D3.4D.5D2. 3D2.D.2D$2A.A.2A13.D3.D.2D2.D3.D3.3D5.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D9.D3.
D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$3.A3.2A11.D3.D.D7.D4.D6.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D 3.D9.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$2C.C.2A2.A10.D3.D.D7.D4.D6.D3.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D
3.D3.D9.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$2C.C2.A.A12.4D.D7.2D3.D7.2D2.4D.5D2.4D2.4D2. 4D3.2D2.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D$4.CA2.2A44.D$5.A.A43.3D$5.A.A$6.A10$3.A.
2A31.D42.3D$3.2A.A31.D25.D15.D3.D$.2A17.D.2D3.3D3.4D.D2.D9.3D3.4D.5D
2.3D2.D.2D6.D$A3.2A14.2D2.D.D3.D.D5.D.D9.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D4.D$
4A.3A12.D5.D3.D.D5.3D9.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D7.D$8.A11.D5.D3.D.D5.D2.D8.D5. D3.D3.D3.D5.D6.D$2.2C.3A12.D6.3D3.4D.D3.D.5D2.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D$2. 2C.A13$2C72.D11.D17.D21.D$A2.C.A28.D29.D5.D3.D11.D17.D21.D$.3A.3A13.
3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D8.D3.D7.5D.D.2D8.4D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D3.3D2.4D3.4D$4.A 3.A11.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D3.D5.D3.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D 3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$.2A.A2.2A11.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D11.D.D.D3.D5.D3.D3.D7.D
3.D.D3.D.D3.D.3D3.5D.D3.D.D3.D$.A.A16.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D11.2D.2D3.D5.D 3.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D2.D2.D5.D3.D.D3.D$21.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D5.5D.D3.
D3.2D5.2D.D3.D.5D.4D3.3D3.3D2.D3.D2.4D.D3.D2.4D14$C2.C.C2.C23.D6.2D 27.D6.2D$4A.4A13.D9.D7.D17.D9.D7.D$4.A15.5D2.4D.4D4.D4.3D8.5D2.4D.4D 4.D4.3D$2.A3.3A13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D$2.4A2. A13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D$6.A15.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D
13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D$2.4A.4A12.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3.4D.5D4.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3. 4D$2.C2.C.C2.C13$4.C27.D6.2D27.D6.2D17.D$C2.C.C2.C13.D9.D7.D17.D9.D7.
D11.D4.2D$4A.4A11.5D2.4D.4D4.D4.3D8.5D2.4D.4D4.D4.3D4.D5.D$4.A17.D3.D
3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.5D3.D$2.A2.4A13.D3.D3.D.D3.D 3.D3.5D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.5D3.D5.D$2.3A3.A13.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D13.D3.
D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D7.D5.D$6.A16.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3.4D.5D4.2D2.4D.4D4.2D3.4D8. 3D$2.4A.4A$2.C2.C.C2.C$6.C11$4.2A93.2D$.2C2.A64.D5.D23.D$C.C2A15.D.2D 3.3D3.3D3.3D2.4D3.3D2.D.2D3.4D.5D7.D3.D2.3D10.D4.3D3.3D2.4D$C4.3A12.
2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D.D3.D3.D5.D3.D3.D.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D
3.D.D3.D$.C2A4.A11.D5.5D.D3.D.5D.D3.D.5D.D5.D3.D3.D5.D3.D3.D.5D9.D3.D 3.D.D3.D.D3.D$3.A.3A12.D5.D5.D3.D.D5.D3.D.D5.D5.D3.D3.D5.D4.D.D2.D13.
D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$3.A.A14.D6.4D2.4D2.4D.D3.D2.4D.D6.4D4.2D3.2D4.D4.4D .5D3.2D3.3D3.3D2.4D$4.A31.D79.D$33.3D80.D12$2A34.D9.2D18.D8.2D27.D17.
D27.D7.D6.2D15.D$2C34.D3.D4.D2.D3.D13.D9.D27.D17.D27.D7.D7.D15.D$5.2A
14.D.D3.3D3.4D8.D11.3D3.4D9.D4.3D2.4D3.3D8.D.2D3.3D3.3D2.D2.D9.4D.4D
3.4D7.4D4.D4.3D3.4D.D2.D$4.A.A13.D.D.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.3D5.D3.D3.D.D3.D 9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.2D2.D.D3.D.D3.D.D.D9.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D 3.D.D5.D.D$CA2.A15.D.D.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D4.D6.D3.5D.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D
3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.3D9.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.3D$C.A.A15.D 3.D.D3.D.D3.D3.D4.D6.D3.D5.D3.D9.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D.D 2.D8.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D7.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.D5.D2.D$2.A.A.2C12.D3.D2.3D3.4D3.
2D3.D6.2D3.4D2.4D.5D3.2D3.3D2.D3.D2.4D.5D.D3.D2.3D3.3D2.D3.D.5D2.4D.D
3.D2.4D.5D.4D4.2D3.3D3.4D.D3.D$2.A.A.A89.D$.2C.A.A86.3D$4.A.A.C$4.A2.
AC$2.A.A$2.2A$7.2C$7.2A6$4.2A.2A$5.A.A20.D$5.A.A12.4D9.3D2.D.2D3.4D2. 3D$2.CA.A.2A11.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D.D5.D3.D$C2.A.A2.C11.D3.D3.D3.5D.D 5.D5.5D$2A.A.AC13.D3.D3.D3.D5.D5.D5.D$.A.A16.4D4.2D3.4D.D6.4D2.4D$.A.
A16.D$2A.2A15.D12$4.2C.A.2A9.D6.2D15.D$.A.C.A.2A.A9.D7.D5.D9.D37.D$A.
2A.A14.4D4.D9.4D2.D2.D3.3D2.D.2D9.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$A3.2A14.D3.D3.D 5.D3.D3.D.D.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D3.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$.2A17.D3.D3.D5.D
3.D3.D.3D3.5D.D11.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D$3.2A.A13.D3.D3.D5.D3.D3.D.D2.D2.D 5.D11.D5.D3.D3.D3.D5.D$3.A.2A13.4D4.2D4.2D2.D3.D.D3.D2.4D.D5.5D2.4D2.
4D4.2D2.4D.D14$5.A45.2D$4.A.A21.D23.D5.D5.D5.D$3.A.A2.A11.4D15.4D.4D 4.D9.5D.5D2.3D2.D.2D$.3A2.2A.C10.D3.D3.D9.D5.D3.D3.D5.D5.D5.D3.D3.D.
2D2.D$A3.2A3.C2.CA6.D3.D3.D10.3D2.D3.D3.D5.D5.D5.D3.5D.D$.3A2.2AC3.CA
6.D3.D3.D13.D.D3.D3.D5.D5.D5.D3.D5.D$3.A.A14.4D4.2D2.5D.4D2.4D4.2D4. 2D5.2D4.2D2.4D.D$4.C.C13.D23.D$5.C14.D23.D12$10.2A12.D15.2D$5.2C.C2.A 12.D9.D4.D2.D3.D$4.C.C.3A10.4D.D.2D9.D4.5D2.3D2.D.2D$4.A.C13.D3.D.2D 2.D3.D3.3D5.D3.D3.D.2D2.D$2.C2A.5A9.D3.D.D7.D4.D6.D3.5D.D$.C3.A4.A9.D 3.D.D7.D4.D6.D3.D5.D$.3CA2.A13.4D.D7.2D3.D7.2D2.4D.D$4.A.2A$.CA.A$2.A .A$A.A.2A$2A9$11.2A11.D15.2D$6.2C.C2.A11.D9.D4.D2.D3.D41.D17.D$5.C.C.
3A9.4D.D.2D9.D4.5D2.3D2.D.2D8.D3.D2.4D.D.2D9.4D.4D2.5D$2A3.C.C12.D3.D .2D2.D3.D3.3D5.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D3.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D$A2.C.A
.3A10.D3.D.D7.D4.D6.D3.5D.D11.D3.D.D3.D.D7.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D$.4A.A3.A9. D3.D.D7.D4.D6.D3.D5.D12.D.D2.D3.D.D7.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D$6.A2.2A10.4D.D7.
2D3.D7.2D2.4D.D5.5D3.D4.4D.D7.2D3.4D.D3.D4.2D$3.A.A$3.2A12$9.2A42.D$
10.A23.D17.2D$10.A.2A7.3D3.4D.5D2.3D2.D.2D3.D.D$9.2A2.A6.D3.D.D3.D3.D
3.D3.D.2D2.D.D2.D$6.C4.2A7.5D.D3.D3.D3.5D.D5.5D$6.2CACA9.D5.D3.D3.D3.
D5.D8.D$4.2C4.A10.4D2.4D4.2D2.4D.D8.D$5.C2.2A$5.A.A$A2.A.C.A$4A.2A$4.
A$2.A.A$2.2A7$8.2A14.D15.2D75.2D$8.A.A13.D9.D4.D2.D3.D41.D17.D11.D$10.A10.4D.D.2D9.D4.5D2.3D2.D.2D8.D3.D2.4D.D.2D9.4D.4D2.5D9.D4.3D2.4D 3.3D$9.CA.2A6.D3.D.2D2.D3.D3.3D5.D3.D3.D.2D2.D7.D3.D.D3.D.2D2.D3.D3.D
3.D.D3.D3.D11.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$12.A7.D3.D.D7.D4.D6.D3.5D.D11.D3.D.D 3.D.D7.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D11.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$4.2C.4C.A7.D3.D.D7.D4.D6.D
3.D5.D12.D.D2.D3.D.D7.D3.D3.D.D3.D3.D11.D3.D3.D.D3.D.D3.D$3.C.A.C3.A 9.4D.D7.2D3.D7.2D2.4D.D5.5D3.D4.4D.D7.2D3.4D.D3.D4.2D.5D3.2D3.3D2.D3. D2.4D$3.A.C.C.2A127.D$.3A.C.A.A125.3D$A3.A.C.A2.A$2A2.A.A.A.2A$5.2A.A
$8.A$8.2A!

EDIT2: Here are the posts comparing the monomer and polymer forms of certain catalysts.
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=1878&p=24440#p24845
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=1878&start=75#p25511

EDIT3: Here are the spartan and semispartan catalysts I use right now. I currently use the monomer form of the TWIT, and the less effective dimer form of the block+eater for the sake of clearence.

Code: Select all

http://www.conwaylife.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=1878&start=50#p25301
If anyone wants to test how often their favorite catalysts occur, suggestions are welcome here.
(But please don't post rubbish. And I can only test stable patterns.)
Last edited by Scorbie on November 29th, 2015, 9:30 am, edited 10 times in total.
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

codeholic
Moderator
Posts: 1142
Joined: September 13th, 2011, 8:23 am
Location: Hamburg, Germany

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

That's an interesting metric of how useful a certain catalyst can be on average. But why is the eater1 not in list?
Ivan Fomichev

Scorbie
Posts: 1443
Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

codeholic wrote:That's an interesting metric of how useful a certain catalyst can be on average. But why is the eater1 not in list?
I had to implement the scripts like this:

The 'control' group:
They are here to filter out uninteresting catalyses of a catalyst. For instance, if an opaque boat is in the control group, it will filter out non-unique interactions of a transparent boat or MikeP's catalyst (shown in the example above).
The 'experimental' group:
These are the list of catalysts that I would like to analyze.

The program works by running ptb2 and survive to both groups, and finding out which reactions of the 'experimental' group is not listed in the 'control' group. It works like this because I started this to compare rare catalysts. (I could just dump all the common catalysts into control that case.)

I currently have the opaque block and eater in the control group, as I already know they are really common. That's why they aren't in the list. (But I'm not sure how on earth did opaque catalyses were counted in the transparent block. Last time it only showed me transparent ones.)
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

A for awesome
Posts: 1942
Joined: September 13th, 2014, 5:36 pm
Location: 0x-1
Contact:

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

I would be interested to see the results for these catalysts:

Code: Select all

x = 118, y = 13, rule = B3/S23
69b2o$70bo$2o11b2o45b2o8bobo$o2bo9bo2bo43bo10b2o$2b2o11b2o2bo37b2obo
14b2o16bobobobo12bo$3bobobo8bobobo5bobobo6b2obo2bo3b2o3b2o3bob2ob2o10b obo7bo7bob2ob2obo10bobo$bo2bob2o6bo2bob2o3b3ob2obo6bob4o3bo2bo2bo8bo2b
o8b2o7bobo6bo3bo3bo11bobo$b2obo9b2obo5bo7bo4bobo9b5o9bob2o5bo11b2obo6b 2obob2o4b2o3b3o2b3o$4bo12bo5b2o6b2o3b2ob3o21bo7b5o10bo8bobo6b2o2bo3b2o
3bo$4b2o11b2o20bo2bo7bo10bobo12bo9b2o7bobo10bob2o2b3o$39bobo7bobo9b2o
10b3o20bo12bo2bobo$40bo9bo22bo37bobo$112bo!

(BTS needs to be in the control group for the 4th catalyst)
x₁=ηx
V ⃰_η=c²√(Λη)
K=(Λu²)/2
Pₐ=1−1/(∫^∞_t₀(p(t)ˡ⁽ᵗ⁾)dt)

$$x_1=\eta x$$
$$V^*_\eta=c^2\sqrt{\Lambda\eta}$$
$$K=\frac{\Lambda u^2}2$$
$$P_a=1-\frac1{\int^\infty_{t_0}p(t)^{l(t)}dt}$$

http://conwaylife.com/wiki/A_for_all

Aidan F. Pierce

Scorbie
Posts: 1443
Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

Thanks for the suggestions! The third one is what I call eater and hook with tail, with 'with' having higher precedence Unfortunately that one's a rock catalyst so it wasn't able to work in past searches. Luckily chris_c came up with an experimental version that seems to work with rocks, so I'll test with that.

Could you tell me how exactly the fourth one is different from BTS? Can it catalyze something that BTS can't?

This evening (about 10 hours later) I'll add the eater2, eater3, BTS, bookend to the control group and run the search again.
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

thunk
Posts: 169
Joined: October 3rd, 2015, 8:50 pm
Location: Central USA

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

What exactly is the "kazyan" in the catalyst enumeration? Because Kazyan's actual profile pic is a BTS.
Similarly for the "MikeP", does it refer to the snark catalyst, the AK-94 catalyst, or something else entirely?
"What's purple and commutes?
The Evanston Express."

Kazyan
Posts: 927
Joined: February 6th, 2014, 11:02 pm

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

At a guess and by process of elimination on the catalysts I've mentioned on the forum, probably this:

Code: Select all

x = 11, y = 10, rule = B3/S23
10bo$3b2o5bo$3bo4b2o$o4bo2bo$6o2bo$9bo$2b2o6bo$2bo$obo$2o! And the catalyst most often mentioned alongside MikeP's name is this one: Code: Select all x = 12, y = 9, rule = B3/S23 11bo$2o2bo4b2o$o2bobo2bo$bob2o2bo$2bo4bo$3b2o2bo$4bo3bo$2bo6bo$2b2o6b 2o! Tanner Jacobi Scorbie Posts: 1443 Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am ### Re: Results of catalyst tests @thunk @Kazyan Kazyan's right and I should have been clearer. Sorry about that. I named the second catalyst as MikeP because Sokwe named it "MikeP catalyst 2" in his version of 'catalysts' file long ago and I couldn't find an appropriate name. (Interestingly, MikeP's catalyst 1 was the BTS.) Best wishes to you, Scorbie Scorbie Posts: 1443 Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am ### Re: Results of catalyst tests @A for awesome @Others who would like to suggest catalysts: Could you post working examples for your suggestions? I have to determine the active site (and polymerize them if possible) but all I could find in the sources were these: Code: Select all x = 59, y = 9, rule = LifeHistory 2C3.2C5.A22.A15.A.C.C.A$A2.C2.A5.3A19.A.A13.A.2A.2A.A$.5A9.A3.2A12.A. A2.A11.A3.A3.A$14.AC4.A10.3A2.2A.C11.2A3.2A$.5A14.A.2A6.A3.2A3.C2.CA 9.3A$A2.C2.A10.CA.A.A8.3A2.2AC3.CA7.2A3.2A$2C3.2C9.C.A.A.A10.A.A14.A 3.A3.A$16.2C3.A12.C.C13.A.2A.2A.A$35.C15.A.C.C.A! And I'd like to hear what you would like to call them, as my arbitrary naming sense is not good Okay, I have tested chris_c's new fork with support for rocks and it works great. However, there's a side effect (which I was worrying that it would happen) which is that the rare catalysts have all sorts of snakial rock catalyses in the result. Code: Select all #C A typical example. The beehive_with_tail_thing catalyst has dozens of these. x = 14, y = 25, rule = B3/S23 b2ob2obo$o4b4o$7o$2o4b2o$b2o2b3obo$o4b2o$6bobo$b2o2b2o$3o3b4o$bo2bo2b
3o5$12bo$11bobo$11bobo$8bo3bo$8b4o2$8b4o$8bo3bo$11bobo$11bobo$12bo!

(I forgot to say that the beehive_tail in the census is this, rather than the one used in syringe. Sorry again.)
Shouldn't that be filtered with the eater? Yep. It was supposed to be filtered by an eater, but the current duplicate filtering mechanism of ptbsearch is rather crude. Practically it can only eliminate duplicates of e.g. a block and a transparent block. I'll ask chris if he can do something about it...
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

A for awesome
Posts: 1942
Joined: September 13th, 2014, 5:36 pm
Location: 0x-1
Contact:

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

Scorbie wrote:@A for awesome @Others who would like to suggest catalysts:
Could you post working examples for your suggestions? I have to determine the active site (and polymerize them if possible) but all I could find in the sources were these:

Code: Select all

x = 59, y = 9, rule = LifeHistory
2C3.2C5.A22.A15.A.C.C.A$A2.C2.A5.3A19.A.A13.A.2A.2A.A$.5A9.A3.2A12.A.
A2.A11.A3.A3.A$14.AC4.A10.3A2.2A.C11.2A3.2A$.5A14.A.2A6.A3.2A3.C2.CA
9.3A$A2.C2.A10.CA.A.A8.3A2.2AC3.CA7.2A3.2A$2C3.2C9.C.A.A.A10.A.A14.A
3.A3.A$16.2C3.A12.C.C13.A.2A.2A.A$35.C15.A.C.C.A!
And I'd like to hear what you would like to call them, as my arbitrary naming sense is not good
Here are example reactions for all but one of the remainder:

Code: Select all

x = 88, y = 13, rule = B3/S23
6b2o$7b2o10bo16bo$7bo11bobo13bob2o44bo$2o11b2o4b2o15b2o22b2o2b2o18bobo$o2bo9bo2bo19bo23bo3bo2bo15b2obo$2b2o11b2o2bo37b2obo4b3o$3bobobo8bobob
o16b2obo2bo13bob2ob2o20bo$bo2bob2o6bo2bob2o17bob4o18bo2bo17bobo$b2obo
9b2obo18bobo23bob2o17b2obo$4bo12bo18b2ob3o21bo22bo$4b2o11b2o20bo2bo18b
obo22b2o$39bobo19b2o$40bo!

I couldn't find an actual catalysis for the BTS variant, so I posted the closest thing I've found.
x₁=ηx
V ⃰_η=c²√(Λη)
K=(Λu²)/2
Pₐ=1−1/(∫^∞_t₀(p(t)ˡ⁽ᵗ⁾)dt)

$$x_1=\eta x$$
$$V^*_\eta=c^2\sqrt{\Lambda\eta}$$
$$K=\frac{\Lambda u^2}2$$
$$P_a=1-\frac1{\int^\infty_{t_0}p(t)^{l(t)}dt}$$

http://conwaylife.com/wiki/A_for_all

Aidan F. Pierce

Scorbie
Posts: 1443
Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

Scorbie wrote:Okay, I have tested chris_c's new fork with support for rocks and it works great. However, there's a side effect (which I was worrying that it would happen) which is that the rare catalysts have all sorts of snakial rock catalyses in the result.
Solved that problem! Now will add A for awesome's favorites and run them.
A for awesome wrote:I couldn't find an actual catalysis for the BTS variant, so I posted the closest thing I've found.
I get what you mean! Actually I was comparing variants of BTSs, so I'll try to put yours into comparison as well as the census.
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

Scorbie
Posts: 1443
Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

Ran 2000 soups and fixed everything I could. Here's the result:
(Please note that these are relative values. The precise meaning of these values are: The expected number of unique catalyses per 10x10 soup where the catalyst is allowed to react from gen 18 to gen 50.)
EDIT: The 0.0735 is the form suggested by A for awesome, which allows yet another cell to the catalytic region. Unfortunately the reactions are mostly from reduced steric hindrance, so it doesn't reflect the author's intention.

Code: Select all

#C [[ VIEWONLY ]] x = 234, y = 121, rule = B3/S23 12bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo24bobobo2bo3bo2bo3bo31bo2bobobo2bobobo2bo bobo28bobobo2bobobo2bo3bo2bobobo24bobobo2bo2bobobo2bobobo$b2o$obo9bo 10bo2bo3bo2bo15bo2bobo2bo8bo2bo3bo2bo3bo21bobobo5bo6bo6bo2bo21bo10bo3b o2bo3bo2bo3bo2bo19b2o7bo3bo2bo2bo3bo2bo$2o47b4ob4o42b3ob2obo42bobob2o 46bo2bo$12bobobo6bo2bobobo2bobobo15bo8bobobo2bobobo2bobobo18bo7bo4bo6b o6bo2bobobo17b2obo2bo4bo3bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo14bo2bo6bo3bo2bo2bobob o2bobobo$3b2o46bobo2b2o41b2o6b2o44bo2b2o45b2o$3bo12bo6bo2bo3bo6bo13b2o 3b2o4bo10bo6bo31bo6bo6bo6bo16bobo9bo3bo6bo6bo6bo24bo3bo2bo6bo6bo$4b3o 143b2o$6bo2bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo2bobobo21bo2bobobo6bo6bo28bo2bo6bo6bo2bo bobo25bo2bobobo2bobobo6bo2bobobo21bo2bobobo2bo2bobobo2bobobo6$12bobobo 2bobobo2bobobo31bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo24bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo 28bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo24bobobo2bo2bo$151b2obo2bo$12bo10bo2bo3bo 21bo13bo6bo6bo2bo16bo2bo2b2o4bo6bo2bo6bo22bob4o4bo3bo6bo6bo2bo18bo9bo 3bo2bo2bo$3bo47bobo46b4o3bo42bobo48bobo$2bobo7bobobo6bo2bobobo21bobo7b obobo2bobobo6bo2bobobo16b3o5bo6bo2bobobo2bobobo16b2ob3o6bo3bo6bo2bobob o2bobobo13b2obo7bo3bo2bo2bo$3b2o49bo47bobo48bo2bo47bo$16bo6bo2bo3bo23b 2o6bo10bo6bo6bo14b2o8bo6bo2bo3bo6bo19bobo6bo3bo6bo6bo6bo16b2o6bo3bo2bo 2bo$154bo$9bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo28bo2bobobo2bobobo6bo2bobobo21bo2bo6bo2b obobo2bobobo25bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo2bobobo21bo2bobobo2bo2bo6$12bobobo2bo bobo2bo26bo8bobobo2bobobo2bo3bo2bobobo64bo9bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo $o2bo48bobo96bobo$4o8bo10bo2bo23bo2bobo10bo6bo2bo3bo2bo67bobo8bo3bo2bo 10bo2bo$6bo42bob2o2b3o94bo3bo$2b5o5bobobo2bobobo2bo18b2o2bo3b2o3bo3bob obo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo65b4o5bo3bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo$2bo42b2o3b3o2b3o$ 4bo11bo6bo2bo26bobo6bo10bo6bo6bo67b2o5bo3bo6bo6bo6bo$3b2o47bobo100b2o$ 9bo2bobobo2bobobo2bo26bo5bo2bobobo2bobobo6bo2bobobo71bo2bobobo2bobobo 6bo2bobobo6$12bo3bo2bo3bo2bo3bo2bobobo24bobobo2bobobo2bobobo31bo2bo3bo 2bobobo2bobobo28bobobo2bo3bo2bobobo2bobobo$150b2o3b2o$12bo3bo2bo3bo2bo 3bo2bo17bo14bo6bo6bo22b2o7bo2bo3bo2bo3bo2bo20bo2bo2bo5bo3bo2bo3bo2bo3b o2bo$3bo46bobobob2o44bo2bo45b5o$2bobo7bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo11bob 2ob2obo4bobobo2bobobo2bobobo22b2o7bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo28bo3bo2bobob o2bobobo2bobobo$3bo45bo103bo$16bo6bo6bo6bo10b2o12bo10bo2bo35bo6bo2bo3b o6bo18bobo7bo3bo6bo2bo3bo6bo$153bo$9bo6bo6bo6bo2bobobo21bo2bobobo2bobo bo2bobobo28bo2bo6bo2bobobo2bobobo25bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo2bobobo6$12bo3bo 2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo24bobobo2bobobo2bobobo81bobobo2bo3bo2bobobo2bobob o$50bobobobo$12bo3bo2bo3bo2bo3bo2bo15bob2ob2obo8bo2bo3bo6bo81bo3bo2bo 3bo6bo2bo$bobo45bo3bo3bo95bo$b2obo7bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo12b2obob 2o5bobobo2bo3bo2bobobo71bobo7bo3bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo$4bo47bobo98b2o$4b2o10bo2bo3bo2bo3bo6bo14bobo7bo6bo3bo6bo81bo3bo6bo2bo10bo$53bo$9bo6b o2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo21bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo78bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo2b obobo6$12bo3bo2bobobo2bobobo31bo2bobobo2bobobo35bo2bobobo2bo3bo35bobob o2bo3bo2bo2bobobo$56b2o93b2o3bo$12bo3bo6bo2bo27bo2bo4bo2bo3bo2bo39bo6b o2bo3bo24bobobobo4bo3bo2bo3bo2bo2bo$2b2o47bo2b2o47b2o47b2obobo$2bobob 2o4bobobo2bobobo2bobobo19bobobo7bo2bobobo2bobobo26b2o7bo2bobobo2bobobo 28bob2o3bo3bo2bobobo2bo2bobobo$obob2obo42b2obo2bo92b2o4bo$2o14bo2bo10b o22bob2o5bo6bo2bo3bo35bo2bo10bo23bo3b2o6bo3bo6bo2bo6bo$53bo93b3o$9bo6b o2bobobo2bobobo21b2o5bo2bo2bobobo2bobobo32bo2bo2bobobo6bo20bo11bo2bobo bo6bo2bo2bobobo6$62bo2bobobo2bobobo85bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2$52bo2bo6bo 2bo3bo2bo89bo3bo6bo6bo$52b4o96b2o$62bo2bobobo2bobobo75bobo7bo3bo2bobob o2bobobo$52b4o97b2o$52bo2bo6bo6bo6bo85bo3bo6bo6bo2$59bo2bo2bobobo2bobo bo82bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo6$12bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo24bo2bobobo 2bobobo2bobobo28bo2bobobo2bobobo35bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo$51b2o$16bo2bo3bo2bo6bo15bo2bo9bo2bo3bo6bo2bo21b2o9bo2bo3bo2bo28b2ob2o6bo3bo 6bo2bo3bo2bo$4bo44b2obobo46bobo47bo3bo$bobobo6bobobo2bo3bo2bobobo2bobo bo14bob3o5bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo19bo8bo2bo3bo2bobobo25b3o7bo3bo2bobobo2bo bobo2bobobo$b2o2bo46bo4bo44bo51bobo$5b2o9bo2bo3bo6bo6bo13b2o3b2o4bo2bo 3bo6bo6bo19b3o6bo2bo3bo6bo28b2o5bo3bo2bo6bo3bo6bo$105bo$9bo2bobobo2bob obo2bobobo2bobobo21bo2bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo25bo2bo2bobobo2bobobo32bo2bob obo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo6$50b2o2b2o6bo2bobobo2bo3bo2bobobo28bobobo2bob obo2bobobo2bobobo24bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo$48bo2bo3bo100b2o$48b3o 4bob2o3bo2bo3bo2bo3bo2bo32bo3bo2bo3bo2bo6bo20bo2bo4bo3bo6bo2bo6bo$52b 2ob2obo44b2o49b2o$50bo2bo8bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo18bo2bo6bo3bo2bobobo 2bobobo2bobobo12bobobo7bo3bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo$50b2obo48bobo45b2obo 2bo$52bo9bo2bo3bo6bo6bo19bo8bo3bo6bo2bo3bo6bo15bob2o5bo3bo2bo6bo3bo6bo $52bobo98bo$53b2o4bo2bo2bobobo6bo2bobobo25bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobo bo14b2o5bo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo2bobobo!
I showed you the pictures first because I don't have a flair at naming catalysts.
Here's the census if you are interested. The #comments are the catalyses not filtered by the control group in the original search. I filtered them later.

Code: Select all

(2000 soups)
1157 uniq_ship_eater
1156 uniq_boat
1062 uniq_bookendlike_table
977 uniq_tub
889 uniq_hook_with_tail
850 uniq_dual_eater
611 uniq_long_hook_with_tail
488 uniq_table_table        # -hook_with_tail
475 uniq_twit               # -boat
469 uniq_pi_splitter        # -boat
464 uniq_gourmet
406 uniq_edgy_b_to_g        # -eater_hook_with_tail, strangely not filtered
392 uniq_awesome_2          # -glider eating rxns... Not sure how many.
390 uniq_table
375 uniq_kazyan
369 uniq_awesome_3
355 uniq_eater_hook_with_tail
353 uniq_eater_table
297 uniq_transp_hive
248 uniq_transp_block
210 uniq_reflector_hook
193 uniq_transp_loaf
189 uniq_mikep              # -boat
147 uniq_awesome_bts        # -table
115 uniq_beehive_tail
97 uniq_long_dock
85 uniq_transp_boat         # -boat
83 uniq_ship_eater_variant  # -ship_eater
66 uniq_ship
53 uniq_awesome_1_rock      # 28 out of 81 were trivial, filtered it out manually.
39 uniq_transp_pond
22 uniq_boat_with_tail

Some minor glitches:
1) edgy_b_to_g (the one with frequency 0.203) contained some eater_hook_with_tail catalyses, but I couldn't filter them with the current program. I'm not sure why.
2) A for awesome's BTS has 147 unique reactions, but most of them are there because his/her form has less steric hindrance, not because of the extra cell that can be off.
3) For an unknown reason, filtering the boat from the transparent boat didn't work. I thought it made sense to just subtract the numbers, so I did. (uniq_transp_boat had 1241 reactions, and uniq_boat had 1156 reactions. So I just did 1241-1156 as running the search with filters made no solutions.) But it seems that the numbers are too small... I don't know
4) The tub is definitely undercount, because I added the "rock tub" to the control group. I was worried that pointy catalyst would make use of their pointy edge to do the "rock tub" catalysis. I really don't regret doing that, as I would have done twice more work filtering if it weren't for the rock tub control.

For people who are interested, here's the collection of all unique catalyses. Here you can see some amusing things, like a transparent pond working. If you see something strange, post a reply.

Lastly, here are the exotic names and their relative frequencies in the picture:
I'll appreciate it if anyone can come up with a good name for any of the catalysts.
table_table 0.244
pi_splitter 0.2345
edgy_b_to_g 0.203
awesome_2 0.196
kazyan 0.1875
awesome_3 0.1845
0.124 is the transparent block, by the way.
reflector_hook 0.105
mikep 0.0945
awesome_BTS 0.0735
beehive_tail 0.0575 (I think I should rename it to beehive_tail_thing.)
long_dock 0.0485
and again, 0.0425 is the transparent boat.
ship_eater_variant 0.0415
awesome_1_rock 0.0265
Last edited by Scorbie on November 5th, 2015, 11:39 am, edited 2 times in total.
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

A for awesome
Posts: 1942
Joined: September 13th, 2014, 5:36 pm
Location: 0x-1
Contact:

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

Okay... This is now my absolute favorite catalysis:

Code: Select all

x = 23, y = 12, rule = B3/S23
16b2ob4o$15b2ob3o$13bo2b5o$14bo2b2obo$14b2o2b3obo$2o3b2o9b3o2bo$obobob
o6bob3o4bo$2bobo13b4o$b2ob2o8bobo2b3o$2bobo10b3o3bo$obobobo$2o3b2o!  Edit: oops: Code: Select all x = 19, y = 23, rule = B3/S23 o3bo2bo$o3bobo2bo$obobob2o$b2o3bo$2ob2obo2bo$4b2ob3o$6obo$2o3b4o$bo2b 2obo$2bo2b5o3b2o$13b2o3$14b2o$13bo2bo$13bobo$11bobobobo$10bobobobobo$11bo2bo2bo$12b2ob2o$13bobo$13bobo$14bo!  x₁=ηx V ⃰_η=c²√(Λη) K=(Λu²)/2 Pₐ=1−1/(∫^∞_t₀(p(t)ˡ⁽ᵗ⁾)dt) $$x_1=\eta x$$ $$V^*_\eta=c^2\sqrt{\Lambda\eta}$$ $$K=\frac{\Lambda u^2}2$$ $$P_a=1-\frac1{\int^\infty_{t_0}p(t)^{l(t)}dt}$$ http://conwaylife.com/wiki/A_for_all Aidan F. Pierce M. I. Wright Posts: 372 Joined: June 13th, 2015, 12:04 pm ### Re: Results of catalyst tests Interesting, that second one does exactly what Tropylium asks about here. Here's an attempt at reducing it: Code: Select all x = 8, y = 12, rule = B3/S23 2b2o$2b2o3$o2b2o$2bo2bo$2bobo$obobobo$2obobobo$3bobobo$3bo2bo$2b2o!

gamer54657 wrote:God save us all.
God save humanity.

hgkhjfgh
nutshelltlifeDiscord 'Conwaylife Lounge'

Scorbie
Posts: 1443
Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

Huh, that's pretty interesting. And @A for Awesome aren't there hundreds of results there? You must have put a lot of effort analyzing the results.

Code: Select all

x = 16, y = 15, rule = B3/S23
9bo$8bobo$3b2o3bobo$3bo3b2obob2o$2obobo2bobob2o$obobob2o2bo$2bobobo3bo
$2b2o3b3o2$7b5o$12bob2o$9b2obob2o$10bobo$10bobo$11bo! From this post: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=1651&p=17939#p17936 Here are oscillators playing with that still life. Code: Select all x = 46, y = 22, rule = B3/S23 bo2bo2bo$b7o2bo$8b3o$3b2obo$2bo3b3o$2bobo4bo$b2o2bob2obo$2bobo3bobo$2b ob2obo2b2o18bo4bo$b2o4bobo18b2ob4ob2o$3bobobobo20bo4bo$3bobobob2o$2obo 4bo5b2o25b2o$o2b2obobo5b2o25b2o$2bo3bob2o$3b4o21b3o4b3o$7b2o2b2o2b2o9b 6o2b6o2b2o$3b4o7bo2bo10b3o4b3o3bo2bo$3bo2bob2o4bobo24bobo$8bo3bobobobo
20bobobobo$6bobo3b2o3b2o20b2o3b2o$6b2o!
With a slightly more reduced bounding box and population. the hook can be turned the other way. EDIT: optimized using gmc_nxtman's optimization.
Last edited by Scorbie on November 4th, 2015, 9:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

gmc_nxtman
Posts: 1148
Joined: May 26th, 2015, 7:20 pm

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

A snorkel loop with hook will work just as well:

Code: Select all

x = 23, y = 8, rule = B3/S23
bo$o13b2o2bo$o13bo$b3o3b2o6b3o3b2o$4bo2b2o9bo2b2o$b2obo10b2obo$o2bo10b
o2bo$2o12b2o!  This is also part of a known glider eater: Code: Select all x = 14, y = 11, rule = B3/S23 8bo$3b2o2bo$3bo3b3o$2obo$o2bob2o$2b2obo$6b3o3b2o$9bo2b2o$6b2obo$5bo2bo
$5b2o!  A for awesome Posts: 1942 Joined: September 13th, 2014, 5:36 pm Location: 0x-1 Contact: ### Re: Results of catalyst tests Scorbie wrote:@A for Awesome aren't there hundreds of results there? You must have put a lot of effort analyzing the results. No, actually, I haven't. I just looked through the first few for each catalyst, and checked to see if they had any potential. I think that the modified table, the long dock, and the pi splitter have the most potential out of the catalysts I don't see very often. The long dock does often leave still lives attached to it; is there any way to filter those out? Edit: A possibly useful almost-transparent loaf: Code: Select all x = 9, y = 6, rule = B3/S23 2bo3b2o$3bobo2bo$3bo2bobo$b2o4bo2$o!  Last edited by A for awesome on November 4th, 2015, 8:50 pm, edited 1 time in total. x₁=ηx V ⃰_η=c²√(Λη) K=(Λu²)/2 Pₐ=1−1/(∫^∞_t₀(p(t)ˡ⁽ᵗ⁾)dt) $$x_1=\eta x$$ $$V^*_\eta=c^2\sqrt{\Lambda\eta}$$ $$K=\frac{\Lambda u^2}2$$ $$P_a=1-\frac1{\int^\infty_{t_0}p(t)^{l(t)}dt}$$ http://conwaylife.com/wiki/A_for_all Aidan F. Pierce Scorbie Posts: 1443 Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am ### Re: Results of catalyst tests A for awesome wrote:The long dock does often leave still lives attached to it; is there any way to filter those out? Well, I'm pretty sure it's possible, but not sure if it's worth it. There aren't too many cases of that are there? (I recall seeing about 10 of them) Also, it would discard solutions to e.g. something like this: Code: Select all #C pseudo_bangbang() would blast off a potential g2 receiver, if there are any. x = 31, y = 19, rule = B3/S23 ob2ob2o3b3o$2obobobo2bo$6bo4bo2$13b2o$13bobo$13bo4bo2$15bo4bo2$17bo4bo
2$19bo4bo2$21bo4bo2$23bo4bo2$25bo4bo!

gmc_nxtman wrote:A snorkel loop with hook will work just as well:

Code: Select all

x = 23, y = 8, rule = B3/S23
bo$o13b2o2bo$o13bo$b3o3b2o6b3o3b2o$4bo2b2o9bo2b2o$b2obo10b2obo$o2bo10b
3bo8bobo$3b2o8bo! Tanner Jacobi Scorbie Posts: 1443 Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am ### Re: Results of catalyst tests That's one of my favorites, too! I first saw these at dr (the double signal to thumb I found also has a similar structure ) And similar derivatives keep showing up. Like in the snark. You don't mind if I compare that directly to the eater 2, do you? By the way, it has a compact dimer. Code: Select all x = 12, y = 12, rule = B3/S23 10b2o$5b2obo2bo$4bobob3o$4bobo$2b3ob5o$bo3bo4bo$b4o2bo$4bob2o$b2obo$2b
obo$obob2o$2o!

Okay, I just ran a 1000 soup search and it's piled with unique results. (Seriously. 1.5M of unique results so I couldn't count.) I'm rerunning the search with 50 soups. Will come back in a minute.

Came back. The program cannot filter out duplicates. I'll try to figure out why.
Okay. It was because the drifting catalyst takes too long to recover.
After inspection of the code, I found out that survive cannot filter reactions correctly for catalysts that take more than 10 gens.
You should probably change the source code to work with this catalyst with ptbsearch.
Specifically, in survive.c:89

Code: Select all

        if (firstgen == 0) { firstgen = i; maxgen = i + restorefilter + 10; }
The '10' here should be more than the drifter's recovery time. Change it to about 16 (the drifter's recovery time is typically 14 but just to be safe)
Oh, when you recompile, gcc might use the old *.o files. (You could probably figure out when looking at the progress on the console) So be sure to remove the past object files if it does.
Best wishes to you, Scorbie

Scorbie
Posts: 1443
Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am

### Re: Results of catalyst tests

Congrats to Kazyan: the catalyst you suggested is really versatile, even considering the overlap of the eater3. 68 unique drifter catalyst reactions in 50 soups. I haven't checked much, but these probably cannot be done with the eater3.

Code: Select all

x = 667, y = 590, rule = B3/S23
2b3o2b2o85b2o73b2o79b2o78b2o81b2o65bo6bobo77bo6bobo74bo6bobo$4obob3o 80b2obobo73bobob2o71b2obobo73b2obo2bo81bobob2o62bo3b2ob2o78bo3b2ob2o 75bo3b2ob2o$bo2b3o84bobo77bobo73bobo74bobob3o84bobo62b2ob3obo79b2ob3ob
o76b2ob3obo$2bo3bob2o81bob2o75b2obo73bob2o3b2o2b6o60bobo87b2obo62bo2bo b4o78bo2bob4o75bo2bob4o$b3o5bo78b2obo81bob2o67b2obo8bobo2bo60b3ob5o86b
ob2o59b3ob2o81b3ob2o78b3ob2o$2o2bob4o78bo2b4o75b4o2bo67bo2b4o4bob4o60b o3bo4bo83b4o2bo59b2obobo2bo78b2obobo2bo75b2obobo2bo$2obo2bob2o75bo4bo
3bo75bo3bo4bo61bo4bo3bo3b2o2b2obo59b4o2bo86bo3bo4bo56b2o2b6o77b2o2b6o
74b2o2b6o$b2o3b2obo75b5ob3o77b3ob5o61b5ob3o4bobobo2b3o60bob2o87b3ob5o 56b2obo3bo79b2obo3bo76b2obo3bo$obo3b2o81bobo81bobo69bobo6bo2bo2bo2bo
57b2obo17b2o2b2o69bobo61b2o2bo82b2o2bo79b2o2bo$bo2b2o2bo7b2o67b3obobo 81bobob3o61b3obobo8bo5b2o58bobo15b5o72bobob3o58b2o2b4o79b2o2b4o76b2o2b 4o$11b2obo2bo66bo2bob2o83b2obo2bo59bo2bob2o7b2ob3obo58bobob2o14bo2bo2b
ob2o68b2obo2bo$10bobob3o67b2o93b2o59b2o17b3o58b2o20b2o3bobo52b2o2b2o 15b2o$10bobo242bo4bo2bo76b7o2bo50b5o$8b3ob5o323b3o6bo50bo2bo2bob2o86b 2o$7bo3bo4bo323b3ob2ob2o53b2o3bobo81b2obo2bo$7b4o2bo68b3o2b2o73b3o2b2o 172b3o2bobo51b7o2bo80bobob3o$10bob2o66b4obob3o70b4obob3o170b2ob2o2bo
52b3o6bo80bobo$7b2obo70bo2b3o74bo2b3o174b2ob4o52b3ob2ob2o79b3ob5o$8bob
o71bo3bob2o72bo3bob2o231b3o2bobo78bo3bo4bo$6bobob2o69b3o5bo71b3o5bo 230b2ob2o2bo79b4o2bo$6b2o72b2o2bob4o70b2o2bob4o231b2ob4o82bob2o66b2o
78b2o$80b2obo2bob2o70b2obo2bob2o317b2obo69bo2bob2o73bo2bob2o$81b2o3b2o
bo71b2o3b2obo318bobo70b3obobo73b3obobo$80bobo3b2o72bobo3b2o318bobob2o 73bobo77bobo$81bo2b2o2bo72bo2b2o2bo317b2o73b5ob3o71b5ob3o$561bo4bo3bo 70bo4bo3bo$564bo2b4o73bo2b4o$564b2obo76b2obo$567bob2o76bob2o$567bobo 77bobo$566b2obobo74b2obobo$570b2o78b2o49$10b2o89bo6bobo49bo2b3o3bo94bo
2b3o3bo56b2o79bob3o2b2o60b2o3bo2b2o71b2o3bobo72b2o3bobo$6b2obobo90bo3b 2ob2o51bo2bob2o97bo2bob2o53b2obobo81bob2ob2o61b2obobo75b4o2b2o72b4o2b 2o$7bobo91b2ob3obo51b2obo2b2obo94b2obo2b2obo53bobo83b2ob5o60bob2o3b2o
70b2ob2obob2o70b2ob2obob2o$7bob2o90bo2bob4o50bobo4b3o94bobo4b3o53bob2o 80bobob5o61b3o2b4o70b2o2bo4bo70b2o2bo4bo$4b2obo82b2o9b3ob2o54b2ob2o2b
2o95b2ob2o2b2o50b2obo84b2ob2o3bo59b3o4bobo71b4obobo72b4obobo$4bo2b4o 75b2obobo9b2obobo2bo51bobobo99bobobo54bo2b4o15bo2b3o3bo55b2obo2b4o60b 2o2b2o74b3o2b2obo71b3o2b2obo$bo4bo3bo76bobo11b2o2b6o49bo4bo74b2o22bo4b
o51bo4bo3bo17bo2bob2o56bo2bob2o62b5o2bobo73bob4o74bob4o$b5ob3o77bob2o 10b2obo3bo51b2o3bo74bo2bob2o17b2o3bo51b5ob3o16b2obo2b2obo55bob2o3b2o 61bo3bobobo74bobob2o74bobob2o$5bobo76b2obo14b2o2bo53b2ob2ob3o72b3obobo
16b2ob2ob3o52bobo18bobo4b3o55bob2o3bo61b4obo74bo2b7o70bo2b7o$b3obobo 76bo2b4o12b2o2b4o49b2o2bob3o76bobo16b2o2bob3o48b3obobo19b2ob2o2b2o55b 3o5b2o60bobob2ob2o71bob3obobo71bob3obobo$o2bob2o74bo4bo3bo150b5ob3o70b
o2bob2o20bobobo$2o79b5ob3o90b2o59bo4bo3bo69b2o24bo4bo151b2o$85bobo87b
2obo2bo62bo2b4o95b2o3bo48b2o96b2obo2bo75b2o$10bo6bobo61b3obobo86bobob 3o63b2obo98b2ob2ob3o45bo2bob2o90bobob3o71b2obo2bo$11bo3b2ob2o60bo2bob
2o87bobo70bob2o95b2o2bob3o46b3obobo89bobo74bobob3o59b2o$10b2ob3obo62b 2o90b3ob5o66bobo155bobo87b3ob5o70bobo63bo2bob2o$10bo2bob4o152bo3bo4bo
65b2obobo149b5ob3o84bo3bo4bo68b3ob5o60b3obobo$10b3ob2o155b4o2bo72b2o 149bo4bo3bo83b4o2bo70bo3bo4bo64bobo$10b2obobo2bo155bob2o226bo2b4o86bob
2o70b4o2bo63b5ob3o$10b2o2b6o151b2obo229b2obo86b2obo76bob2o63bo4bo3bo$
10b2obo3bo154bobo232bob2o84bobo73b2obo69bo2b4o$11b2o2bo154bobob2o231bo bo83bobob2o73bobo69b2obo$12b2o2b4o150b2o234b2obobo81b2o75bobob2o71bob
2o$410b2o158b2o75bobo$646b2obobo$650b2o55$3obobobo72bobo2bo2bo77bobo2b
o2bo64b2o88b2o68b4ob2obo81b2o74b2o82b2o$2o2bo2b2o75b4obo80b4obo64bo2bo b2o79b2obobo72bobo79b2obobo74bobob2o73b2obo2bo$3obob3o71b4ob4o77b4ob4o
66b3obobo79bobo77bobo77bobo78bobo73bobob3o$b5o75b2o2bo2bo78b2o2bo2bo 70bobo79bob2o69b3obob4o77bob2o76b2obo73bobo$bob5obo70bobobob4o76bobobo
b4o65b5ob3o74b2obo72bo4bo3bo74b2obo82bob2o68b3ob5o$o5bobo71b2o2bo81b2o 2bo70bo4bo3bo73bo2b4o69b2ob5obo74bo2b4o76b4o2bo67bo3bo4bo$2o3b4o71bo2b
ob2obo77bo2bob2obo69bo2b4o9bobo2bo2bo52bo4bo3bo69bo4bobobo71bo4bo3bo
76bo3bo4bo64b4o2bo$2b3ob2obo71bo2bo4bo77bo2bo4bo68b2obo15b4obo52b5ob3o 70bo4b2o74b5ob3o78b3ob5o67bob2o$b3o5bo70b4o3bo78b4o3bo73bob2o8b4ob4o
57bobo72bobobob2obo75bobo82bobo68b2obo$bo6b2o73bo4bo80bo4bo72bobo10b2o 2bo2bo53b3obobo72b2ob2o2bobo71b3obobo82bobob3o65bobo$246b2obobo7bobobo
b4o51bo2bob2o153bo2bob2o84b2obo2bo62bobob2o$250b2o7b2o2bo56b2o158b2o 94b2o62b2o$259bo2bob2obo$90b2o168bo2bo4bo$85b2obo2bo68b2o97b4o3bo$84bo bob3o69bo2bob2o95bo4bo292b4ob2obo$84bobo74b3obobo396bobo76b5o2bo$82b3o b5o74bobo399bobo71bob5o$81bo3bo4bo70b5ob3o323b4ob2obo58b3obob4o71b3o3b
2o$81b4o2bo73bo4bo3bo326bobo60bo4bo3bo71b2ob4o$84bob2o76bo2b4o329bobo
57b2ob5obo71bobo2bo3bo$2o79b2obo79b2obo325b3obob4o57bo4bobobo74bo2bo2b o$o2bob2o75bobo82bob2o241b2o79bo4bo3bo57bo4b2o74bobo2bo$b3obobo72bobob 2o81bobo237b2obo2bo79b2ob5obo57bobobob2obo71b3o2b2o2bo$5bobo72b2o84b2o
bobo154bobo2bo2bo71bobob3o80bo4bobobo57b2ob2o2bobo71bob2o2bobo$b5ob3o 160b2o157b4obo71bobo84bo4b2o141bob2ob5o$bo4bo3bo314b4ob4o70b3ob5o80bob
obob2obo$4bo2b4o315b2o2bo2bo69bo3bo4bo80b2ob2o2bobo$4b2obo317bobobob4o
68b4o2bo$7bob2o314b2o2bo76bob2o$7bobo315bo2bob2obo69b2obo$6b2obobo314b o2bo4bo69bobo$10b2o313b4o3bo69bobob2o$328bo4bo68b2o47$10b2o68bo3bobob
2o84bo3bobob2o70b2o76b2o88b2o2bobo59b2o77b2o81b2o$6b2obobo71b5obo80b2o 5b5obo70bobob2o72bobob2o84bo5bobo57bobob2o73bobob2o73b2obobo$7bobo77bo
78b2obobo9bo74bobo75bobo88bob2o61bobo76bobo75bobo$7bob2o69bo2bo83bobo 4bo2bo77b2obo74b2obo73b2o10bo2bo2bob2o57b2obo75b2obo75bob2o$4b2obo74b
3o2bo79bob2o5b3o2bo76bob2o74bob2o66b2obobo10b5ob2obo60bob2o75bob2o69b
2obo$4bo2b4o69bobo2b3o76b2obo6bobo2b3o58bo3bobob2o5b4o2bo71b4o2bo67bob o16b3ob2o57b4o2bo72b4o2bo69bo2b4o$bo4bo3bo71bobo3b2o74bo2b4o5bobo3b2o
59b5obo5bo3bo4bo68bo3bo4bo64bob2o11b3o3bo2bo57bo3bo4bo69bo3bo4bo63bo4b
o3bo$b5ob3o71bob5o73bo4bo3bo4bob5o65bo8b3ob5o69b3ob5o61b2obo16b2obob2o 59b3ob5o70b3ob5o63b5ob3o$5bobo72b2o3b2obo72b5ob3o4b2o3b2obo57bo2bo14bo
bo75bobo65bo2b4o11b4o4b2o60bobo76bobo71bobo$b3obobo72b2o5b3o75bobo6b2o 5b3o58b3o2bo10bobob3o71bobob3o58bo4bo3bo13bob6o60bobob3o72bobob3o63b3o bobo8bo2b3o$o2bob2o154b3obobo72bobo2b3o11b2obo2bo71b2obo2bo57b5ob3o83b
2obo2bo72b2obo2bo61bo2bob2o9bobo2bo$2o158bo2bob2o75bobo3b2o14b2o76b2o 61bobo72b2o2bobo11b2o77b2o61b2o11b3ob2o2bo$160b2o79bob5o72bo3bobob2o
71b3obobo72bo5bobo163bo5b4o$15bo2bobo219b2o3b2obo74b5obo70bo2bob2o76bo b2o166b2ob4obo$14b6o3bo216b2o5b3o77bo72b2o78bo2bo2bob2o166b3obo$14b2o 2b3obo297bo2bo156b5ob2obo70b2o2bobo85b2ob2o$15b3ob2ob2o298b3o2bo156b3o
b2o70bo5bobo84b2obo3bo$14b2obo5bo296bobo2b3o152b3o3bo2bo73bob2o85bo2b 2o2bo$14bo2b2ob4o298bobo3b2o152b2obob2o71bo2bo2bob2o83b2o4b2o$15bobo3b 2o298bob5o152b4o4b2o70b5ob2obo$15bo3b3obo76b2o218b2o3b2obo153bob6o74b
3ob2o$14bob3ob2obo71b2obo2bo218b2o5b3o230b3o3bo2bo$14bob2obobobo70bobo
b3o461b2obob2o$94bobo463b4o4b2o$92b3ob5o461bob6o$91bo3bo4bo$91b4o2bo$94bob2o$91b2obo$92bobo$90bobob2o$90b2o49$10b2o81b2o66bo2b5o91bo2b5o74b
o2b5o76b2o52bob3obo79bob3obo74b2o$6b2obobo81bobob2o67bobo96bobo79bobo 71b2obo2bo52b4o82b4o77bobob2o$7bobo85bobo62b3o2bo2bo90b3o2bo2bo73b3o2b
o2bo70bobob3o56bobob3o79bobob3o73bobo$7bob2o83b2obo63b3o3bo92b3o3bo75b 3o3bo71bobo57b2o2b4o78b2o2b4o74b2obo$4b2obo89bob2o59bo2bo2b2obo89bo2bo
2b2obo72bo2bo2b2obo49bo2bobo12b3ob5o57b2o3bo80b2o3bo75bob2o$4bo2b4o83b 4o2bo60bobobo3bo90bobobo3bo73bobobo3bo49b2ob2o2b2o8bo3bo4bo55bo4b2o79b o4b2o73b4o2bo$bo4bo3bo83bo3bo4bo56b2obobo2b2o89b2obobo2b2o72b2obobo2b
2o50b3o3bobo7b4o2bo58b2ob2o2bo78b2ob2o2bo72bo3bo4bo$b5ob3o85b3ob5o56bo b3o2bobo89bob3o2bobo72bob3o2bobo50b5o2b2o10bob2o57b5o2b2o77b5o2b2o73b 3ob5o$5bobo89bobo60b2ob3obobo89b2ob3obobo72b2ob3obobo50b3o2b2obo7b2obo
59b2o4b4o76b2o4b4o75bobo$b3obobo89bobob3o58bo2b5o91bo2b5o74bo2b5o50b3o 3b3o8bobo59bo5b3o77bo5b3o76bobob3o$o2bob2o12bo2b3o59bo2b3o8b2obo2bo
296b2ob5o7bobob2o83b2o145b2obo2bo$2o17bobo2bo59bobo2bo13b2o295b6ob3o6b 2o82b2obo2bo150b2o$16b3ob2o2bo56b3ob2o2bo311b3o4bo90bobob3o134b2obobob
3o$15bo5b4o55bo5b4o150b2o78b2o78b3o3b3o90bobo138b2ob2o3b2o$16b2ob4obo
56b2ob4obo150bo2bob2o73bo2bob2o170b3ob5o54b2o78b3o5b2o$19b3obo60b3obo 152b3obobo73b3obobo168bo3bo4bo54bo2bob2o73b2obobob2o$15b2ob2o60b2ob2o
160bobo77bobo168b4o2bo58b3obobo72b3obo3b2o$16b2obo3bo57b2obo3bo152b5ob 3o71b5ob3o169bob2o62bobo72b4obobobo$15bo2b2o2bo57bo2b2o2bo153bo4bo3bo
70bo4bo3bo165b2obo61b5ob3o72bo2b2obo$16b2o4b2o57b2o4b2o155bo2b4o73bo2b 4o166bobo61bo4bo3bo69b3o3bobo$244b2obo76b2obo167bobob2o63bo2b4o69b2obo
2bo$247bob2o76bob2o164b2o67b2obo73b2o2bo$247bobo77bobo237bob2o$246b2ob obo74b2obobo235bobo$250b2o78b2o234b2obobo$570b2o3$170b2o$165b2obo2bo$
164bobob3o$164bobo$162b3ob5o$161bo3bo4bo$161b4o2bo$164bob2o$161b2obo$162bobo$160bobob2o$160b2o41$b2o79b3o93b3o69b2o78b2o68bob4o3bo89bob4o3b
o61b2o78b2o$bobob2o74bo4bo90bo4bo63b2obobo74b2obobo68b2o2b3obo90b2o2b 3obo58b2obobo74b2obobo5bob4o3bo$3bobo74b5o2bobo86b5o2bobo61bobo12b3o
62bobo25b3o43b2o3bo2bo90b2o3bo2bo58bobo77bobo7b2o2b3obo$2b2obo76bo3b2o 90bo3b2o63bob2o10bo4bo60bob2o23bo4bo40b2obo95b2obo64bob2o76bob2o7b2o3b o2bo$5bob2o73b2ob3o90b2ob3o60b2obo12b5o2bobo54b2obo25b5o2bobo40bo2bo
95bo2bo58b2obo76b2obo9b2obo$2b4o2bo72b2obobo2bo87b2obobo2bo58bo2b4o11b o3b2o56bo2b4o24bo3b2o40b3o2b4o90b3o2b4o55bo2b4o73bo2b4o9bo2bo$2bo3bo4b
o69bob3obo89bob3obo57bo4bo3bo11b2ob3o53bo4bo3bo24b2ob3o39bo2bo2bo73b2o
17bo2bo2bo55bo4bo3bo70bo4bo3bo7b3o2b4o$3b3ob5o68b2ob3o3bo86b2ob3o3bo 55b5ob3o11b2obobo2bo51b5ob3o24b2obobo2bo38b2o4b3o70bo2bob2o13b2o4b3o 52b5ob3o71b5ob3o7bo2bo2bo$5bobo72bo2b3obobo86bo2b3obobo59bobo13bob3obo
57bobo26bob3obo39bo4b5o71b3obobo11bo4b5o56bobo5bob4o3bo62bobo10b2o4b3o
$5bobob3o68b2o2bo4bo86b2o2bo4bo55b3obobo12b2ob3o3bo51b3obobo25b2ob3o3b o37b2obobo2bo76bobo11b2obobo2bo53b3obobo5b2o2b3obo59b3obobo9bo4b5o$6b
2obo2bo227bo2bob2o13bo2b3obobo50bo2bob2o26bo2b3obobo118b5ob3o70bo2bob
2o7b2o3bo2bo57bo2bob2o10b2obobo2bo$11b2o227b2o18b2o2bo4bo50b2o31b2o2bo 4bo55b2o61bo4bo3bo69b2o11b2obo63b2o$103b2o308b2obo2bo64bo2b4o85bo2bo$98b2obo2bo307bobob3o65b2obo86b3o2b4o$97bobob3o308bobo72bob2o82bo2bo2bo
$2obobob3o87bobo60b2o248b3ob5o68bobo84b2o4b3o$2ob2o3b2o85b3ob5o56bo2bo
b2o242bo3bo4bo67b2obobo81bo4b5o$3o5b2o84bo3bo4bo57b3obobo241b4o2bo74b 2o81b2obobo2bo$2obobob2o85b4o2bo64bobo244bob2o$3obo3b2o87bob2o60b5ob3o 239b2obo$4obobobo84b2obo63bo4bo3bo239bobo$2bo2b2obo86bobo66bo2b4o237bo bob2o$3o3bobo84bobob2o65b2obo240b2o$2obo2bo86b2o72bob2o$b2o2bo161bobo$166b2obobo$170b2o54$10b2o69b5obobo70b3ob2obo76b2o75b5obobo84b5obobo67b 2o91b2o56bo2b2ob3o$6b2obobo69bo3b2obo71b2o3b2obo75bobob2o70b2o2bo2b2o
84b2o2bo2b2o68bobob2o82b2obo2bo57b4ob3o$7bobo71bob2o2bobo70b3o2bo3bo 76bobo71bobob2o87bobob2o73bobo82bobob3o57bo2bob4o$7bob2o69b3o5bo73b2ob
ob2o76b2obo72b3o2bo87b3o2bo71b2obo82bobo64b2obo$4b2obo72b2o2b5o74b2obo 81bob2o71bo2b4o86bo2b4o71bob2o62bob3o2bobo5b3ob5o60b2o$4bo2b4o69b6obob
o72bobobo14b2o62b4o2bo68bob2o5bo83bob2o5bo68b4o2bo69bo6bo3bo4bo56bobo
2b2o2bo$bo4bo3bo7bobo3bo59b3ob2o71b2o5bo12bobob2o58bo3bo4bo65b5obobo 84b5obobo69bo3bo4bo60b3obo2bo5b4o2bo59bob2o2bo2bo$b5ob3o9bo3bob2o55bob
3obo72bobobob3o13bobo60b3ob5o66b3ob2o2bo84b3ob2o2bo69b3ob5o61b5obo8bob
2o63bo3bo$5bobo11b4o3bo54b2obob2obo73bobobobo12b2obo62bobo70b2o2b2obo 11b2o58b2o12b2o2b2obo72bobo63bo4b2obo5b2obo63bo6b2o$b3obobo10b2ob2ob2o
bo53bobobob3o71b3ob2o18bob2o59bobob3o66bo3b4o6b2obo2bo58bo2bob2o7bo3b
4o72bobob3o59bo6bobo5bobo62bob3ob4o$o2bob2o12b2o5bo155b4o2bo60b2obo2bo 78bobob3o60b3obobo87b2obo2bo58bobo2bo2bo4bobob2o$2o17bobo2b4o154bo3bo
4bo62b2o78bobo68bobo92b2o58bobob2ob3o3b2o$18bobo4bobo155b3ob5o140b3ob 5o60b5ob3o150bo2bo3bobo$18bob5ob2o157bobo143bo3bo4bo60bo4bo3bo70b5obob
o71b3o94b2o$18bo4bobobo157bobob3o139b4o2bo66bo2b4o69b2o2bo2b2o164b2obo 2bo$19b5obobo158b2obo2bo141bob2o66b2obo72bobob2o166bobob3o$191b2o138b 2obo72bob2o70b3o2bo165bobo$100b2o138b3ob2obo84bobo72bobo73bo2b4o160b3o
b5o$95b2obo2bo138b2o3b2obo81bobob2o70b2obobo68bob2o5bo159bo3bo4bo$94bo
bob3o139b3o2bo3bo80b2o78b2o68b5obobo160b4o2bo$94bobo145b2obob2o232b3ob 2o2bo162bob2o$92b3ob5o142b2obo234b2o2b2obo160b2obo$91bo3bo4bo141bobobo 234bo3b4o161bobo$91b4o2bo143b2o5bo399bobob2o$94bob2o143bobobob3o398b2o$91b2obo148bobobobo$92bobo146b3ob2o$90bobob2o$90b2o52$bo2b2ob3o71bo2b
2ob3o82b2o82b2o62b2o$2b4ob3o72b4ob3o82bo2bob2o77bobob2o58bobob2o$bo2bo
b4o71bo2bob4o83b3obobo61b2ob2o2bo9bobo61bobo$4b2obo76b2obo89bobo60b2o 3b2o10b2obo60b2obo$4b2o78b2o87b5ob3o59b2ob2o14bob2o60bob2o$obo2b2o2bo 70bobo2b2o2bo83bo4bo3bo57b2obob3obo7b4o2bo57b4o2bo$ob2o2bo2bo70bob2o2b
o2bo86bo2b4o57bo2bobobo9bo3bo4bo54bo3bo4bo$4bo3bo75bo3bo87b2obo61b5ob 3o8b3ob5o55b3ob5o$bo6b2o71bo6b2o71b2ob2o2bo10bob2o59bo3bo13bobo61bobo$ob3ob4o70bob3ob4o70b2o3b2o12bobo58b6obo12bobob3o57bobob3o$161b2ob2o12b
2obobo56b4o2bob2o11b2obo2bo57b2obo2bo$21b2o137b2obob3obo12b2o56b2ob4ob o17b2o62b2o$16b2obo2bo80b2o55bo2bobobo$15bobob3o76b2obo2bo56b5ob3o$15b
obo79bobob3o58bo3bo$13b3ob5o75bobo60b6obo$12bo3bo4bo73b3ob5o56b4o2bob
2o$12b4o2bo75bo3bo4bo56b2ob4obo$15bob2o75b4o2bo$12b2obo81bob2o$13bobo
78b2obo224b2ob2o2bo$11bobob2o78bobo223b2o3b2o$11b2o80bobob2o223b2ob2o$93b2o226b2obob3obo$321bo2bobobo$322b5ob3o$323bo3bo$321b6obo$321b4o2bob
2o$321b2ob4obo!  Best wishes to you, Scorbie Scorbie Posts: 1443 Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am ### Re: Results of catalyst tests @A_for_awesome Apologies for making that BTS comparison late. That kinda takes some time as I have a lot of variants to compare with. A for awesome wrote: Scorbie wrote:@A for Awesome aren't there hundreds of results there? You must have put a lot of effort analyzing the results. No, actually, I haven't. I just looked through the first few for each catalyst, and checked to see if they had any potential. I think that the modified table, the long dock, and the pi splitter have the most potential out of the catalysts I don't see very often. I'm not sure what you mean by 'potential' reactions. Could you elaborate? I personally think that the more catalysts occur, the more effective it is. Still, I pretty much decided not to be too sure about everything unless I really know. So believe yourself. (This change of mind is due to seeing the census results.It was pretty surprising to me, especially the exotic looking ones that are common.) Best wishes to you, Scorbie A for awesome Posts: 1942 Joined: September 13th, 2014, 5:36 pm Location: 0x-1 Contact: ### Re: Results of catalyst tests Scorbie wrote:@A_for_awesome Apologies for making that BTS comparison late. That kinda takes some time as I have a lot of variants to compare with. A for awesome wrote: Scorbie wrote:@A for Awesome aren't there hundreds of results there? You must have put a lot of effort analyzing the results. No, actually, I haven't. I just looked through the first few for each catalyst, and checked to see if they had any potential. I think that the modified table, the long dock, and the pi splitter have the most potential out of the catalysts I don't see very often. I'm not sure what you mean by 'potential' reactions. Could you elaborate? I personally think that the more catalysts occur, the more effective it is. Still, I pretty much decided not to be too sure about everything unless I really know. So believe yourself. (This change of mind is due to seeing the census results.It was pretty surprising to me, especially the exotic looking ones that are common.) By potential, I mean that these catalysts haven't been used much before and running searches with them should yield many new conduits. x₁=ηx V ⃰_η=c²√(Λη) K=(Λu²)/2 Pₐ=1−1/(∫^∞_t₀(p(t)ˡ⁽ᵗ⁾)dt) $$x_1=\eta x$$ $$V^*_\eta=c^2\sqrt{\Lambda\eta}$$ $$K=\frac{\Lambda u^2}2$$ $$P_a=1-\frac1{\int^\infty_{t_0}p(t)^{l(t)}dt}$$ http://conwaylife.com/wiki/A_for_all Aidan F. Pierce Scorbie Posts: 1443 Joined: December 7th, 2013, 1:05 am ### Re: Results of catalyst tests Comparisons of BTS variants, Part 1 - Versatility TL;DR? • This is the post to read if you want to look for a variant that works with the most situations. And not worried about small search time differences. • I compared these four BTS variants: Code: Select all #C STD, PIERCE, BOOKEND, TABLELESS forms of BTS respectively. x = 53, y = 7, rule = LifeHistory .2C.C2.C8.2C.C2.C8.2C.C2.C8.2C.C$2.A.4A9.C.4A9.A.4A9.A.3A$A.A12.A.A 12.C.A12.A.A4.A$2A.3A9.2A.3A9.CA.3A9.2A.5A$3.A2.A11.A2.A11.A2.A11.A$
3.A2.A11.A2.A11.A2.A11.A.A$4.2A13.2A13.2A13.2A! • The bookend part and the additional cell in A for awesome's suggestion have little effect. • If you have tabloids in your catalyst list, try the form without the table. Less intrusive. • If you don't have tabloids in your catalyst list, try the form with the table. Additional table catalysis. Anyway, for who's interested: Here is a comparison of BTS variants to find out various catalytic sites and their enhancements on catalysis in a quantitative manner. I made some 10x10 random soups, and let the BTS variants to react with them from gen 18 to 80. So... Warning: the results here should not be compared directly to the "relative catalyst frequencies" above. (Oh, this must have been why the drifter Kazyan suggested was so versatile... Whoops...) Here are the BTS variants I compared. Code: Select all #C STD, PIERCE, BOOKEND, TABLELESS forms of BTS respectively. x = 53, y = 7, rule = LifeHistory .2C.C2.C8.2C.C2.C8.2C.C2.C8.2C.C$2.A.4A9.C.4A9.A.4A9.A.3A$A.A12.A.A 12.C.A12.A.A4.A$2A.3A9.2A.3A9.CA.3A9.2A.5A$3.A2.A11.A2.A11.A2.A11.A$
3.A2.A11.A2.A11.A2.A11.A.A$4.2A13.2A13.2A13.2A! Note: A for awesome's additional cell catalysis only work if the white cell in the following picture has 3 neighbors and that usually means that the red cell has to be on. Code: Select all x = 8, y = 7, rule = LifeHistory .2A.A2.A$2.A.4A$A.C$2A.D2A$5.A$4.A$4.2A!  From common sense, variants with less steric hindrance and more catalytic areas seemed to be more versatile, so I tried to compare forms that took the least space and added the catalytic activities to each. If you think some other factor should be tested, please post a reply. I compared the standard form with the other three forms. Comparing the STD and TABLELESS forms were a bit not obvious, but I think you could see what I did when you see the results. I explained further below. Here are the results. Code: Select all #Note: Trivially, there aren't any unique results of STD when compared with BOOKEND or PIERCE variants. BTS_PIERCE - BTS_STD = 2/1000 #Had to search 1000 because there weren't any in 50 soups BTS_BOOKEND - BTS_STD = 9/1000 BTS_TABLELESS - BTS_STD = 18/50 BTS_STD - BTS_TABLELESS - SNAKE - BOOKENDLIKE_TABLE = 2/50 BTS_STD - BTS_TABLELESS - SNAKE = 26/50 Which is pretty evident to see what's going on in the first three tests. Additional bookend or A for awesome's catalysis is pretty rare. BTS_TABLELESS has unique catalysis other than those of BTS_STD because it takes up less space. It's not toooo obvious in the fourth and fifth cases, so here goes if you don't get it: The fourth case compares STD with TABLELESS but filters out all unwanted catalyses. The STD form could have snake and table-only catalyses, so both are filtered. I used the table analogy of the bookend catalyst instead of the table because I think that might be the one used more often with the BTS. (No spartan restrictions, more versatility.) So the 2/50 is the relative frequency of the "BTS && Table" catalyses occurring at the same time, which is the only unique catalysis of a table-form BTS, compared to a tableless BTS, in my opinion. The fifth case compares STD with TABLELESS, but without filtering tables, in case you don't use any tablish catalysts with the BTS. This shows 26/50. So I guess 24/50 of it would be the relative frequency of the "table only" catalysis. That's All. Attachments cmp_bts.zip The actual reactions (3.6 KiB) Downloaded 280 times Best wishes to you, Scorbie A for awesome Posts: 1942 Joined: September 13th, 2014, 5:36 pm Location: 0x-1 Contact: ### Re: Results of catalyst tests A few more potential catalyses: Code: Select all x = 24, y = 104, rule = B3/S23 18b2o$18bo$16bobo$2o14b2o$2o4b2o$5bobo$5bobo$5b2o7b2o$13bo2bo$14b2obo$17bo$17b2o3$18b2o$18bo$11bo4bobo$12bo3b2o$10bobo$9bo2bo$9bo4b2o$13bo2b
o$8b2o4b2obo$17bo$17b2o5$15b2o$15b2o2$11b2o$10b4o2b2o$10b2ob2ob2o$12b 2o$20bo$18b3o$17bo$11bo5b2o$11bo$12bo$12b2o2b2o$13b2ob2o$13bo3$16b2o$
16b2o3$16b2o$14bobobo$18bo$12bobo3bob2o$12bo4b2ob2o5$13bo2b2o$13bo2bob o$14bo3bo$12bobo3bob2o$17b2ob2o4$16b2o$16b2o3$16b2o$16bobo$18bo$13b3o
2bob2o$15bob2ob2o$14bo3$17bo$17bo$16bo$16bo2b2o$18bobo$18bo$16bobo$14b
3obobo$13bo5b2o$13b2o2$16b2o$16b2o3$16b2o$16bobo$18bo2bo$18bobobo$13b 3ob2obobo$15bo4bob2o$14bo5bo$18bobo\$18b2o!

x₁=ηx
V ⃰_η=c²√(Λη)
K=(Λu²)/2
Pₐ=1−1/(∫^∞_t₀(p(t)ˡ⁽ᵗ⁾)dt)

$$x_1=\eta x$$
$$V^*_\eta=c^2\sqrt{\Lambda\eta}$$
$$K=\frac{\Lambda u^2}2$$
$$P_a=1-\frac1{\int^\infty_{t_0}p(t)^{l(t)}dt}$$

http://conwaylife.com/wiki/A_for_all

Aidan F. Pierce